Timothy Woods
Published by Timothy Woods
Last Updated On: April 19, 2023

At first glance, FreshDirect and ButcherBox seem to have very different business models. However, both companies offer high-quality meats that are potential options for a Carnivore diet.

As experts on the Carnivore lifestyle, we subjected both companies' meat to a taste test over three months and the results of this research are in this article.

ButcherBox vs FreshDirect: Key Differences

Freshdirect box top view with logo overlay

The main difference between FreshDirect and ButcherBox is in their business structure.

For these meal delivery services, FreshDirect is an a la carte grocery delivery service, while ButcherBox is an online meat delivery service.

FreshDirect offers a wide selection of grocery items, including produce, dairy, frozen foods, and more.

Although meat is one of its many offerings, it is by no means the primary or only focus.

The meat quality is similar to any other grocery chain, although they offer organic and direct-from-the-farm options.

ButcherBox, on the other hand, specializes exclusively in meat delivery.

It offers a monthly subscription service with a selection of meats sourced from humanely raised animals through sustainable and responsible practices.

Comparing Their Features Head to Head

Butcherbox and Freshdirect box and product comparison

These two food delivery services come with several features that help differentiate them.

1. Selection

ButcherBox's selection is more streamlined and focused than FreshDirect. ButcherBox offers a variety of beef, pork, and chicken sourced from around the U.S.

They have a good mix of steaks, ground beef, chops, and breasts.

FreshDirect delivery service offers a larger variety of meat options than ButcherBox. In addition to beef, pork, and chicken, they have a wide selection of fish, shellfish, lamb, veal, and turkey.

Their pork selection is extensive - you can get ground pork, Italian sausage, pork breakfast sausage, pork tenderloin, thick cut bacon, and pork chops.

2. Quality

Freshdirect box with fruits and logo overlay

FreshDirect provides meats that are organic and pasture-raised. They offer a variety of poultry options, including free-range, organic chicken.

The FreshDirect wild caught seafood is fresh and tasty.

They ensure the quality of their offering by having none of their animals treated with antibiotics or growth hormones.

ButcherBox's meat is also antibiotic and hormone-free.

They specialize in humanely-raised, heritage-breed pork, grass-finished beef, and organic and pasture-raised chicken, resulting in high-quality offerings across their entire menu.

3. Sourcing

Both FreshDirect and ButcherBox offer quality, ethically and humanely sourced meat. Neither company has a significant advantage in this area.

ButcherBox meat is all free from antibiotics and growth-promoting chemicals.

They also work with family farms in Australia that adhere to their standards on pasture-raising and humane treatment. Their pasture-raised pork comes from local farmers in the American midwest.

We believe in fair labor practices. In line with our family and community values, we seek partners who treat their employees as part of a team - and we’re ever thankful for that team.
- ButcherBox

FreshDirect offers organic, non-GMO, pasture-raised meat, and farm-direct optons. All those choices are also antibiotic and growth hormone-free.

Finally, FreshDirect offers a local opportunity for sustainable seafood - delivering regional favorites like lobster, crab, and shrimp.

4. Pricing

Giving money to someone

ButcherBox is a meat subscription service that offers various meat subscription boxes starting at $137 per month.

You can choose between all-beef box, a beef and chicken box, a mixed box, or a beef and pork box. For an extra $22 per month, you can also get the ability to create a custom box.

They also offer meat boxes that are 16-22 lbs of meat priced at $253 per month.

FreshDirect's grocery delivery offers meat, poultry, and fish ordered a la carte. You can filter their meat selection by preparation requirements, dietary preferences, or cut of beef.

Their prices vary greatly based on the cut and weight of the meat you select. For example, their organic ground beef is $11.99 per lb. while a grass-fed ribeye is $19.99 per lb.

5. Packaging

ButcherBox boxes all of its meat products in recyclable material. They use dry ice or frozen gel packs to ensure that the meal kits arrive at the proper temperature to give you a safe and fresh product.

Since FreshDirect brings your filet mignon, chuck roast, or flank steak directly to you via courier after leaving the store, its packaging does not need to have the rigor of delivery service.

Your meat will arrive in a sturdy box and store packaging but without significant additional insulation. Instead, it is shipped in refrigerator-freezer trucks so that it arrives dry and cool.

6. Shipping

Butcherbox and freshdirect delivery packages

ButcherBox sends your monthly order with free shipping. They offer service anywhere in the continental United States, and you have the option to pick the day of the month that you want to receive your insulated box.

FreshDirect has far less reach than ButcherBox. It is available only in parts of New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, Pennsylvania, Delaware, and Washington, D.C.

Their standard service is delivered within three-hour windows either the same day or day after your order.

You can upgrade to an express delivery which will get your order to you within two hours but only with a limited assortment of food.

7. Cancellation

FreshDirect is an online grocery delivery company that offers a one-stop shop for wide range of food.

It functions as an a la carte service, so you can call for only the food you want and when you want it. There is no penalty for not ordering and no cancellation fee.

In contrast, ButcherBox is a meat delivery subscription-based service that will send you a curated box of meat every month.

You have the option to change the frequency of your deliveries, and you can cancel the entire service at any time without penalty.

8. Customer Service

Talking to someone while wearing a headset

When it comes to comparing customer service, ButcherBox is the winner. This company offers phone, email, and online chat support with agents who are knowledgeable and quick to respond.

Additionally, they have an excellent online FAQ that contains tons of helpful information.

FreshDirect's website offers phone, message, and chat support. They also have a good FAQ on their website.

Unfortunately, the "Contact Us" link on their home page was broken, and I had to do a web search to get their phone number and other contact details.

Once I could contact them, the service was friendly and helpful.

Related Articles:

ButcherBox vs FreshDirect: Our Final Thoughts

When it comes to these two meat delivery services, we find that ButcherBox is the clear winner. FreshDirect has a much smaller delivery area, and the quality of their meat is much like you see in any grocery store.

ButcherBox, on the other hand, offers a wide variety of high-quality meats like sirloin steaks, ground beef, and chicken breasts that are delivered fresh to your door.

Their prices are slightly higher than FreshDirect, but they are the best meat delivery service for convenience without sacrificing quality.

Check out our review for more information about ButcherBox meat delivery.

#1 Meat Delivery Service


Opening a box of Butcherbox meat products inside
Meat Quality
Menu Options
Overall Score
  • Grass-fed and grass-finished beef delivered directly to your door
  • Without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of June
  • No organ meat
Was this article helpful?

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *