Timothy Woods
Published by Timothy Woods
Last Updated On: April 1, 2022

Two companies that are often compared when it comes to meat delivery services are Holy Grail and ButcherBox. Both of these companies offer a great selection of grass-fed and humanely raised beef, but which one should you choose?

To determine the best meat delivery services, we tried out the online meat delivery of both companies in an extensive three-month taste test. Here’s some data to help point you to the winner.

ButcherBox vs Holy Grail Steak: Key Differences

Burger patties on Holy Grail Box with logo overlay

The main difference between the two delivery services is that Holy Grail Steak offers top-end gourmet meat from around the world a la carte.

The company's delivery options mean that you can order as much or as little Kurobuta pork or American wagyu as you want, whenever you want

At the same time, ButcherBox delivers monthly subscriptions of quality Australian beef and other meats. They send you a subscription of your chosen preset or custom meat box each month.

Comparing Their Features Head to Head

1. Selection

Butcherbox products on tabletop with box package

ButcherBox is the winner when it comes to total variety. They have a much more extensive selection of meat because they source not only grass-fed beef, but also chicken and pork - breasts, drumsticks, tenderloin, and pork chops.

They act like an online butcher, providing steak lovers sirloin steak and heritage pork directly to the consumer.

Although Holy Grail Steak company does provide some pork products, it focuses mainly on steaks. The variety and sourcing of their beef are wide. They include wagyu options from America and Australia, as well as from locations in Japan like Kobe, Hokkaido, Sendai, and many more.

Their beef offerings are substantial, from NY strip steaks to USDA Prime black Angus, wagyu burgers, Denver steak, and filet mignon. This is the only delivery service for dry aged steaks from Japanese wagyu and American wagyu beef.

Neither company offers more eclectic fare like wild caught seafood, beef tallow, foie gras, or wild boar. Nor do they sell breakfast sausage, Italian sausage, chuck roast, or free bacon.

But they both have excellent choices of hormone-free, grass-fed, organic meat such as ground beef, flank steak, skirt steak, strip steak, and chicken breasts.

2. Quality

When it comes to pure, unadulterated meat, ButcherBox is high quality. They don't offer any other types of food, but they make up for it with an impressive range of quality meats. All of their beef is pasture-raised and grass-finished, and all of their chicken and pork is organic.

With this pasture-raised beef, free-range organic chicken, and humanely-raised pork, ButcherBox provides top quality meat fresh to your door.

Holy Grail Steak is a different kind of company. It specializes in the top cuts of beef from around the world. Wagyu beef, known for its intense marbling and flavor, is one of Holy Grail's main offerings [1]. Renowned for their Kobe beef, Holy Grail also offers American Prime and Australian Wagyu.

3. Sourcing

Feeding grass to a black cow

ButcherBox partners with farms that adhere to strict standards for the humane treatment of animals.

They also only use meats free from hormones, antibiotics, and other growth-promoting chemicals.

They preferentially source their meat from small family farms that usually supply the local grocery store or a small butcher shop. This way, they know they are shipping meat raised to the highest standards.

Holy Grail sources beef from all over the world and are committed to working with partners that do not use antibiotics or hormones.

These global farms provide humane living conditions for their livestock and sustainable pasturing for their beef cattle.

In the end, both of these meat delivery services are excellent options for those looking for ethically and humanely sourced meat.

4. Pricing

ButcherBox is a meat subscription service that offers various meal kits. The classic subscription starts with 8-11 lbs. of meat and costs $137 per month. Larger kits cost $253 per box for twice as much food.

The box can be preset - all beef or a mixed box with pork or chicken. You can also make a custom order from this online meat delivery company.

Holy Grail offers a wide variety of world-sourced beef online. The pricing largely depends on the a la carte option the customer chooses. Ground beef may only cost $16 per lb., but Kobe beef is upwards of $359 for a single steak. American wagyu is about $50-80 depending on the cut of meat.

5. Packaging

Front view of a Butcherbox packaging

ButcherBox ensures your order arrives fresh and on time in eco-friendly packaging. They use gel packs or dry ice as needed to keep the temperature of your order within the optimal range.

Holy Grail vacuum-seals and then blast freeze their meat products to guarantee freshness and flavor.

Bringing the meat quickly to -30F preserves the flavor and protects the food. It is then shipped in a recyclable box with dry ice. Even the shipping foam is ecologically sound as the box comes with a biodegradable interior insulator.

6. Shipping

ButcherBox is the only meat delivery company that offers free shipping on all its boxes [2]. They offer deliveries to the 48 contiguous states and provide a tracking number so you can track your order. Once you have signed up for this monthly service, it will deliver on your day of choice.

Holy Grail Steak Co. does offer free shipping on all orders $199 and above. After that, they charge $29.99 for standard ground shipping and $99.99 for overnight shipping by 1-day air. However, they ship steaks for delivery only on Tuesday through Saturday and only in the lower 48 states.

Both companies will let you do a gift or care package with the products.

7. Cancellation

With Holy Grail Steak Co, you can simply order whenever you want, and that is the only time you will receive your meat. So if you're looking for the utmost flexibility, D'Artagnan gives you complete control over your meat delivery.

With a signature beef delivery company like ButcherBox, you have to adjust your service if you go on vacation or take a break from meat for any other reason. However, you have total freedom to extend the intervals between deliveries or even cancel the entire subscription.

8. Customer Service

Call center operator

My experience with these two companies' customer service departments has been excellent - both meat delivery services were able to answer my questions quickly and satisfactorily.

Additionally, I couldn't find any negative comments about customer service when I did my research.

Both meat delivery services offer easy customer service with phone and email support. However, ButcherBox has a more robust Frequently Asked Questions section on their website and is the only one that offers online chat support.

ButcherBox vs Holy Grail Steak: Which One Is the Best Meat Delivery Service?

When it comes to Holy Grail or ButcherBox, we find that ButcherBox is the clear winner. They offer everyone access to high-quality meats at a price that will not break the budget.

ButcherBox has quality grass-fed Australian beef that, if not the same as getting Kobe beef from Japan, is exceptional for the price.

Holy Grail may offer top meat from around the world, but that incremental increase in quality comes at a price that is far too high for Carnivores who are just trying to put meat on the table regularly.

Whether talking about their beef, pork, or chicken options, ButcherBox’s delicious meat, free shipping, and efficient delivery makes them win this round as one of the best meat delivery services.

Check out ButcherBox at their site.

#1 Meat Delivery Service

ButcherBox

Opening a box of Butcherbox meat products inside
Price
5.0
Meat Quality
5.0
Menu Options
4.4
Shipping
4.8
Overall Score
4.8
Pros
  • Grass-fed and grass-finished beef delivered directly to your door
  • Without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of May
Cons
  • No organ meat

Was this article helpful?

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.