As two of the oldest meat delivery companies in the United States, it can be tough to choose between Omaha Steaks and Allen Brothers. Both offer high-quality meat delivered throughout the country.

So, to help you avoid the lesser brand, we ran a thorough comparison of Omaha Steaks vs Allen Brothers. Let’s dive in.

Primary Differences Between Omaha Steaks & Allen Brothers

Contrasting Omaha Steaks & Allen Brothers

Though Omaha Steaks and Allen Brothers have many similarities, many factors set the two apart.

For one, Allen Brothers offers a wider selection of Wagyu beef cuts than Omaha Steaks.

On the flip side, Omaha offers more in the way of complete ready-made meals as well as desserts and wine.

Omaha Steaks:

  • Complete wine selection
  • Wide assortment of one-step meals
  • Special free shipping packages
  • Large recipe resource section

Allen Brothers:

  • Steak subscription box options
  • Wider selection of Wagyu beef
  • Larger selection of poultry types
  • Offers elk and other game meats

Allen Brothers vs Omaha Steaks Menu Options

Both companies offer a wide variety of meats with a large number of cuts for each variety. One of the key differences between the two is the pre-seasoned and ready-made meals that each company offers.

Popular cuts from each include:

Omaha Steaks:

  • Private Reserve Ribeye Crown Steaks
  • Bone-In New York Strips
  • Fully Cooked Sliced Chicken Breast

Allen Brothers

  • USDA Prime Boneless Ribeye Steaks
  • The Great Steakhouse Steak Burgers
  • Berkshire Bone-In Pork Chops

Best for menu options: Omaha Steaks

Sourcing Practices

raw meat

Both Omaha Steaks and Allen Brothers have similar sourcing practices for much of their meat. Each company allows you to select from either grain-fed beef or grass-fed and grain-finished steaks.

One thing that gives Omaha Steaks a slight edge is that all of their meat is sourced from the same area in Nebraska (1).

Omaha Steaks:

  • Grass and grain-fed beef
  • Sourced from ranches around Nebraska
  • 21-day aging process

Allen Brothers:

  • Wet/Dry aged grass and grain-fed beef
  • Seafood sourced from a variety of areas
  • Free-range chicken breasts

Best for menu options: Omaha Steaks

Meat Quality: Omaha Steaks or Allen brothers?

Omaha Steaks and Allen brothers are both medium to high in terms of quality. Each also has some points that stand out over the other company.

For one, the grass-fed and grain-finished beef that Omaha Steaks offers provides better quality meat. However, Allen Brothers has more in the way of USDA Prime and wagyu (2).

Omaha Steaks:

  • Grass-fed meats
  • Extensive marbling
  • Freshly caught seafood

Allen Brothers:

  • Well-marbled Wagyu
  • USDA Prime
  • Wet aged beef

Best for menu options: Tie

Shipping & Delivery

delivery

Both companies charge for shipping and offer standard as well as expedited shipping options.

The primary difference between the two in terms of shipping and meat delivery is that Omaha Steaks base the shipping costs on the total order price.

On the other hand, Allen Brothers charges shipping cost per item.

Both companies regularly have free shipping discounts. This usually ranges from 50% off shipping costs or free shipping for orders over a certain amount.

Best for shipping and delivery: Omaha Steaks

Pricing & Plans

Omaha Steaks and Allen Brothers are both considered medium-high to upper-priced meat delivery companies. They both offer lower-priced options such as cheaper cuts of meat and burgers that are less than steaks.

With that said, you can find high-end cuts from Wagyu to USDA prime as well as high-priced foods such as caviar on both websites. Allen Brothers also offers high-prices monthly steak subscriptions though we recommend companies like Butcher Box for subscription services.

Best for pricing: Tie

“Great products! Yes, a little pricier than some places, but they guarantee everything 100%, so if you don't like something or happen to get a bad item, they will make it right.”

 

- Dana Hendricks, Verified Omaha Steaks Facebook Reviewer (3)

Recommended Article: Our Favorite Meat Delivery Boxes

Customer Support

Compared to Omaha Steaks, Allen Brothers offers more ways to get in touch if you need customer support.

Both companies have an easy to find the phone number for customer service in the form of an 800 number at the top of the website.

With that said, Allen Brothers also offers a fax number, online contact form, and a resource page. Omaha Steaks only has a resources page for customer support aside from their phone number.

Best for customer support: Allen Brothers

FAQs

steak faqs

What is similar to Omaha Steaks?

There are over a dozen steak delivery companies online, with many of them offering similar products. The companies that are similar to Omaha Steaks are:

 

  • Butcher Box
  • Snake River Farms
  • Porter Road
  • Crowd Cow
  • Holy Grail Steaks Co.
  • Chicago Steak Co
  • Kansas City Steak Company
  • Fossil Farms
  • Moink Box
  • Carnivore Club

What grade of meat is Omaha Steaks?

Omaha Steaks range from choice grade beef to USDA prime and Angus. USDA Prime is the highest level that the United States Department of Agriculture certifies. This beef is characterized by lots of marbling and typically is produced from younger and well-fed cattle.

Is Omaha Steaks overpriced?

Generally, yes. Omaha Steaks comes at a wide range of prices. While their pricing is typically more than you would pay in a grocery store, you are paying an added cost for the convenience of having meat shipped to your door. Their meats are also typically of a higher quality than you would find at a grocery store.

Allen Brothers or Omaha Steaks? We Choose …

In this direct comparison of Omaha Steaks vs Allen Brothers, we’ve noticed a lot of similarities in their meat quality and price range. While we are impressed with Omaha’s seafood and Allen’s marbled Wagyu, we think there’s a better deal than these two mail-order companies, and that’s ButcherBox.

ButcherBox offers grass-fed and grain-finished beef that has the best buttery taste every time. They also have an extensive variety of other products from common cuts of beef, chicken, and pork to less common items like seafood.

You also get to curate your own subscription box and have it delivered to your doorstep, free of charge.

ButcherBox meat

Butcher Box

Our #1 Recommendation

  • Grass-fed beef delivered directly to your door
  • Without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
Click For Best Price
payment icons

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *