There are countless online meat providers to choose from, and finding the right one can be tiring. And the moment you start reading those online comments, figuring out what’s good and what’s not tends to become an overwhelming experience.

Recently, we've tried Omaha Steaks, one of the largest providers. Let's see how they stack up in that department which will hopefully help you make the right choice for yourself.

What Is Special About Omaha Steaks?

Omaha Steaks is one of the oldest companies in the meat delivery business. They have been around for a whopping 166 years, with humble beginnings as a local butcher shop in a city between Nebraska and Iowa.

Interestingly, they shipped their first steak in 1952 via mail order. But we've come a long way since shipping food via mail order, and now they’re one of the largest online meat delivery shops in the country.

On their menu, you'll find everything from beef, pork, and chicken, to desserts and side dishes, such as grilled potatoes and other fresh vegetables.

Pros
  • Gift package options
  • Shipping in all 50 states and territories
  • Complete meal packages
  • Regular Omaha Steaks holiday special offers
Cons
  • Some high price items
  • No free shipping
  • Portion size can be small
  • Sometimes hard to reach customer service rep

How Are The Menu Choices?

Omaha Steak packaging

The first time I wanted to order, I noticed a large variety of meat products and other food to choose from, including desserts and appetizers. They also have gift boxes that can be custom designed and shipped based on your preferences. Some options include:

  • Filet Mignon
  • Burgers
  • Pork Chops
  • Chicken Breast

 

  • Hot Dogs
  • Fish Filets
  • Sirloins
  • Cheesecake

 

  • Baked Potatoes
  • French Fries
  • Cheesecakes
  • Dessert Wines

Does Omaha Steak Have Quality Meat?

Based on our experience and according to customer testimonies, their steak quality is premium. During our Omaha Steaks review, we found the filet to be particularly tasty. The flavor is good, and the fact that you receive a good portion made it all the more favorable.

Word is that Omaha Steak tends to be expensive, but let's be real, filet mignon tends to cost a lot of money anyway. Actually, until you get into the larger packages or the juiciest cuts of meat, ordering food from Omaha Steaks isn't all that expensive than getting it from the local store. In fact, the selection and quality are far better than what most supermarkets offer these days.

One thing to note, however, is that cattle are grain-finished, so they are not 100% grass-fed.

Is Omaha Steaks Overpriced?

Omaha Steaks are overpriced according to some comments left on review sites, such as Trust Pilot. Other commenters note that the products are of a high caliber and worth the money. Based on our experience, they are of reasonable value.

The cost of each product varies greatly and you can find everything from high-end Wagyu to lower-cost beef cuts. Some examples of price include:

For Under $100

  • King Cut 36oz NY Steak
  • Top Sirloin Cap Roast
  • Chicken Fried Chicken

 

For Under $50

  • Premium Ground Beef
  • Brisket Burger
  • Steakhouse Sweet Potato Fries

How Are The Sourcing Practices?

filet mignons

They source all of their meats from local ranches in the state of Nebraska. The state is renowned for having some of the best cattle in the United States.

The animals are mostly raised on a grass-fed diet and grain-finished for a better gourmand experience. Their meats are all flash frozen so that the fibers are not damaged as much.

Related Article: Is ButcherBox A Good Deal?

Ordering Process

The experience of ordering is relatively smooth. For our Omaha Steaks review, we ordered filet mignons from their official website.

It was easy to add the product into the online cart and pay for everything. After checkout, we received an order number for later review. They accept a range of payment options, making it easier to complete the checkout.

Are Omaha Steaks Shipped Fresh or Frozen?

Omaha Steaks are shipped frozen to ensure they retain their freshness. Every product is packed in a gift box with dry ice and the package is then placed in a styrofoam container to ensure the product remains cool during delivery.

The dry ice will be enough to keep orders frozen during transportation. But there may be some shipping costs depending on the subtotal.

How Is The Customer Service?

ribs and newyork strips

Their support team operates seven days a week. You can get in touch with a representative by contacting their toll-free phone number during the hours of:

  • Weekdays - 7 am to 10 pm
  • Saturday - 8 am to 7 pm
  • Sunday - 9 am to 5 pm

They also answer a lot of questions on their website fact center. Their support page is quite extensive, making the experience of ordering from them much easier overall.

Omaha Steaks Product Guarantee

Something we liked about the provider is they offer a satisfaction guarantee. If you aren’t completely satisfied with your order, you have two options. You can either request a refund or have them send you a new order.

Omaha Steak Reviews

beef stick and steak bites

After an extensive review of Omaha Steaks, we found them to be an adequate company. Their products are usually fresh, and they provide shipping to more locations than most online meat providers. Here are some additional ratings.

BBB Rating

They have been accredited with the BBB since 1966 and has an A+ rating. They have 17 customer ratings with an average of two out of five stars and 96 registered complaints (1).

Trust Pilot

Trust Pilot happy customer review

Omaha Steak real customer review

They have feedback from 16 customers with an average of 3 out of 5 stars. 31% of people rated them as excellent, and 31% as bad (2).

Yelp

They have 236 ratings on Yelp with an average rating of 2.5 out of five stars. Many of the complaints seem to center around pricing and portion size (3).

Facebook Page

The company has over 400,000 likes on its Facebook page. They have a rating of 4.1 out of five based on the opinion of over 20,000 people (4).

FAQs

steak for dinner

How long are Omaha Steaks good for once thawed?

Omaha steaks are good for 3 to 5 days once thawed in the refrigerator. They must be cooked during this time, or they may spoil.

Do Omaha Steaks have additives?

Omaha Steaks do not have additives. All of their meats are shipped fresh and are sourced from non-factory farms that practice optimal animal raising methods.

Is Omaha Steaks Worth It?

Omaha Steaks can be worth it if you are looking for higher caliber meat than you would typically find at your local grocery store.

They offer a good experience overall with a wide variety of food options from single order meats to complete meals, including sides and desserts. Another advantage is consistent shipping throughout the country.

But based on our research we believe there is a better option. Out of all the companies we’ve reviewed, ButcherBox has been better for consistent and premium-quality meats.

They are more affordable with a freshness that is at the same level or higher. If you’re looking for top-notch flavor delivered throughout the US, make sure to check out ButcherBox as well.

ButcherBox

#1 Recommended Meat Delivery

ButcherBox

  • High-quality meat delivered right to your door
  • Humanely raised without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable meat orders available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
Click For Best Price
payment icons

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *