Timothy Woods
Published by Timothy Woods
Last Updated On: June 22, 2022

Both ButcherBox and Omaha Steaks are well recognized for their high quality meat and great meal delivery services.

However, many people claim that the two have some subtle differences that make one slightly more advantageous than the other.

We decided to put this claim to the test, and after many hours of research and three-month-long testing, we’ve gathered a few interesting facts for you.

Let’s discuss them below.

A Quick Comparison Between ButcherBox and Omaha Steaks

comparing Butcher Box and Omaha Steak

The main difference between Omaha Steaks vs ButcherBox lies in their sourcing practices. The ButcherBox provides sustainably sourced beef and free-range organic chicken, while Omaha Steaks offers traditionally sourced prime meat cuts that aren’t grass-fed.

While both are meat delivery services, Omaha Steaks does not offer free shipping or a subscription plan like its competitor.

This company charges tiered shipping costs based on product quantity.

ButcherBox

The company started with the idea that 100% grass-fed beef should be available to everyone. The meat delivery service ​offers high-quality meats from pasture-raised farms.

  • Custom and curated meals
  • High quality beef and humanely sourced meat
  • Free from antibiotics and no added hormones. (Federal regulations prohibit the use of hormones or steroids in poultry.)

Omaha Steaks

Known as "America's Original Butcher," this meat delivery began as a neighborhood butcher shop. It has one of the largest selections of meats we've seen, including prime beef.

  • Abundant meat
  • Custom meal kits
  • Known for high meat quality

Which Has a Better Meat Selection?

ButcherBox and Omaha Steaks comparison

At first glance, it would seem that Omaha Steaks is the winner when it comes to meat in a box option and different small or big cuts. Indeed they have plenty more to choose from.

Upon closer inspection, I found that the company wasn't always a good option for the carnivore diet. Many of the premium meats this meat delivery service sells are pre-seasoned and come with non-carnivore diet sides.

Their options include chicken, beef, and pork. You may save time in seasoning before cooking, but even small condiments are not recommended for carnivore dieters.

With ButcherBox, you get the best grass-fed beef, heritage breed pork, and free-range organic chicken. Every flavorful meat Omaha Steaks uses is no doubt hand-picked and of good quality. It's no-nonsense, and I also don't have to worry about their meats messing with my diet.

Comparing Their Sourcing Practices

ButcherBox has one of the best reputations for food sourcing practices out of the various meal delivery services, including Omaha steaks, Porter Road, the Thrive Market, and Snake River Farms.

ButcherBox

  • Only sources clean, high quality meat from family farms that are free from GMOs and hormones.
  • From their grass-fed beef to organic chicken to heritage breed pork, all of their products are sustainably sourced and humanely raised.
  • For years, they only pick the best butcher shops and farms to be the company's partners.

Omaha Steaks

  • It doesn't focus on the additive-free and clean eating market, as proven by their pre-seasoned steaks.
  • They sell traditionally sourced prime cuts of meat but are not grass-fed.

Menu Options

We noted above and in our Omaha Steaks review that this meat delivery offers more choices. But, its competitor options are more plentiful if you are on the carnivore diet. I'm a big fan of their heritage pork box and breakfast sausage.

ButcherBox offers top-notch grass-fed beef steaks and other beef cuts. To name a few of the best options are chuck roast, sirloin steaks, beef burgers, strip steaks, bacon, and filet mignon.

For fish and seafood lovers, I've found their sockeye salmon to be a real treat.

Overall, ButcherBox subscription has a wide variety of meats to choose from than Omaha Steaks. It's easy to mix and match your custom meal box and purchase it. It won't even take up much of your time. Just don't forget to use paper towels.

Research spanning three decades suggests that grass-based diets can significantly improve the fatty acids (FA) composition and antioxidant content of beef…

- Amber Abbott 

College of Agriculture, California State University

Is There a Difference in Quality?

Both ButcherBox and Omaha Steaks also offer high-quality beef, only one specializes in clean eating. ButcherBox's founding mission was to "make grass-fed beef more accessible."

Each one of their item in the ButcherBox catalog is clean and free of chemicals and hormones, which makes it a great selection for carnivore dieters. Even when you're new to the diet, their choices will significantly help in your transition.

The goal is that you can cook a restaurant-grade steak or other great meat in your kitchen. So if you're looking for top-tier cuts, great value, and a rich meaty flavor, I lean towards choosing the box. This is something Omaha Steaks delivery has not guaranteed.

The company also has a quality gourmet meat selection with cuts like NY strip steak, pork tenderloin, and rib-eye steak. But, it doesn't have the guarantee that its products in a box are clean and additive-free.

However, as a carnivore diet follower, I view meat as more than a food source. It's the very foundation that provides me energy and sustenance throughout the day.

So, food quality is at the top of my list when evaluating these two services. If you're on the same diet like mine, choose wisely between the quality of Omaha Steaks and ButcherBox options.

Related Comparison Guides:

What About Pricing?

meat delivery

ButcherBox and Omaha Steaks offer custom meal options; the latter one ​offers gourmet meat packages or pick and choose orders. While its rival has monthly ​delivery with four main meal kits and a custom box option.

You can have your meat shipped bi-monthly or every month. Omaha Steaks offers quality gourmet meat cuts, but the pricing tends to be higher.

However, I wouldn't choose it if you’re geared more toward healthy meat delivery at a more affordable per meal price point (by pounds or per box).

Overall, I believe the ButcherBox service is more affordable for carnivore diet practitioners, especially with the custom box. Using Omaha Steaks regularly, your order in a box will add up fast, especially when you're looking into availing their products for more years to come.

Shipping Cost

Omaha Steaks’ delivery costs are also higher compared to ButcherBox. The money I save each year on shipping quickly makes up a month of meals.

Plus, I consider the waiting and shipping time (if I ran out of my supply, I have to go out looking for frozen meat in the grocery, which will cost more).

ButcherBox

  • Free shipping on their mail delivery
  • Sent in dry ice packaging and is frozen
  • Offers delivery ​around the US
  • Order individual items or in bulk
  • Can send bi-weekly or monthly

Omaha Steaks

  • Charges tiered shipping cost based on how much you buy and do not deliver to US territories like Puerto Rico.
  • When it comes to the shipping time, my packages arrived 1 - 3 days after they charge the credit card. One time there was a delay in delivery and they informed me in advance, and then a few days later they proactively applied a $30 credit to my account.

Packaging & Deliverability

Omaha Steaks on the table

ButcherBox makes all deliveries in small gift boxes packed with free dry ice to make sure your heritage breed pork chops and grass-fed ground beef arrive without issue.

Their meat is shipped vacuum-packed to ensure freshness upon arrival for your carnivore diet meal plan. With ButcherBox, you can track all of your packages easily from their website for a hassle-free purchase.

The company delivers throughout the 48 contiguous states, excluding Hawaii and Alaska.

When I asked, they noted import and export restrictions, which prevented shipping outside the continental US. Omaha Steaks do not offer all of these services.

Customer Support & Service

I've had only positive experiences with the customer service with both meat delivery services. Both have online customer service representatives that respond in time, on their site, or via phone call. But, because the latter focuses on clean meat, they have been better at answering my past questions.

As a carnivore diet follower, my focus is specific. I want to find the highest quality and cleanest meat I can get that is cost-effective. The ButcherBox service is more in line with most people's needs than Omaha Steaks.

Here’s What Customers Are Saying

User reviews for both companies were somewhat mixed, but we encountered more positive testimonials for ButcherBox than Omaha Steaks:

“I must say I love Butcher Box. I have tried many different meat companies in the past year or so, and so far they have been the best.”

- Brett P

On Trustpilot

“The site gives you flexibility in choosing your next box meat selections, as well as ship date, and shipping frequency. Without exception, I receive my box within 1-2 business days after the billing date.”
- Sabrina M
On Trustpilot

“I realized that the box saves me a lot of time at the supermarket and I reckon their prices are pretty similar to budget places like Costco.”
- Kristen F
On Trustpilot

Here’s what customers are saying about Omaha Steaks: 

“I sent a box of steaks as a gift to each of my four children. They told me they all loved the quality and the taste of the meat.”
- Elizabeth C.
On Sitejabber

“For me, it’s not worth it by a long shot. They used to be really good, but now I feel they are just a brand.”
- Slow_D-oh
On Reddit

“We did order a couple of times back in the day but we became regulars during the pandemic. We usually order the better cuts, such as Prime Reserve, I must say they are pricey but pretty good.”

- Jerry S.

On Trustpilot

Omaha Steaks vs ButcherBox - Which One Should You Buy?

Based on our experience with both meat brands, we felt that ButcherBox is the clear winner of quality meat supply.

I especially liked the fact that they value clean meat, product selection for carnivore dieters is well-rounded, plus their products are overall less costly compared to Omaha Steaks as you save a lot on order and delivery costs.

All things considered, we feel ButcherBox is just a better overall choice if you want a rich meaty flavor for your meals.

#1 Meat Delivery Service

ButcherBox

ButcherBox
Price
5.0
Meat Quality
5.0
Menu Options
4.4
Shipping
4.8
Overall Score
4.8
Pros
  • Grass-fed and grass-finished beef delivered directly to your door
  • Without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of June
Cons
  • No organ meat

Was this article helpful?

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.