Timothy Woods
Published by Timothy Woods
Last Updated On: April 11, 2021

With so many different steak companies available, you don’t want to end up with a package full of mediocre products that you paid top dollar for. That's what happened to me.

At Carnivore Style, we try to take out the guesswork by comparing two steak delivery services, Chicago Steak Company and Omaha Steaks. We think the Chicago Steak Company has the edge. Keep reading to find out why in this Omaha Steaks vs Chicago Steak Company review.

Primary Difference Between Omaha & The Chicago Steak Company

The primary difference between Omaha Steaks and Chicago Steak Company start with their menu. The Chicago Steak Company has a more diverse list of grass-fed beef, including USDA prime, wet-aged, and dry-aged steak cuts.

Omaha doesn’t have any great-tasting meat options as far as we can tell. They label their item as USDA inspected.

Another key difference is the quality, which we really think ties back into the grade that each steak company provides for steak lovers. The Chicago Steak Company specializes in the best 3% of beef in the world, while Omaha gives more budget meal options that don’t taste as flavorful.

Chicago Steak Company Highlights

  • USDA prime beef
  • Wet and dry-aged
Omaha Steaks Highlights

  • USDA Choice
  • Angus beef
  • Ships to US, Canada, and Puerto Rico
  • Fast delivery

Menu Options

high quality meat

With its roots in the Union Stock Yards of Chicago, the Chicago Steak Company has more popular beef options to choose from, such as USDA prime beef, American Wagyu beef chops, filet mignon, baby back ribs, New York strip steak, pork chops, T-bone, and an assortment of aged steaks depending on your preference. Omaha Steaks meat delivery offers a well-selected portion of USDA Choice.

Based on their websites, both companies offer humanely-raised, growth hormone-free, and antibiotic-free beef, but Chicago’s website seems to be lacking a grain-fed beef section. They both offer great seafood, lamb, veal, filet mignon, heritage pork chops, and chicken breasts.

Chicago’s Selection

  • Wagyu burgers
  • Turkey
  • Filet mignon
  • Angus
  • Foie gras
  • Kurobuta pork
Omaha’s Selection 

  • Wine and Ham
  • Desserts
  • Family butcher shop services
  • Black Angus burgers

Sourcing Practices

As per our Chicago Steak Company review, they source their beef from cattle in the mid-west region. They partner with excellent local and family farmland to ensure that high-quality standards are met and ensure an ultimate steak experience for satisfaction guarantee.

In our Omaha Steaks review, we found that since they are such a large and popular establishment, they source the best steaks from family farms and butcher shops all over the United States.

Chicago’s Sourcing 

  • Mid-west region sourcing
  • Heritage cattle
  • Grain or corn-fed options
  • Free-range
Omaha’s Sourcing 

  • Grass-fed and grain-finished beef
  • Sourced from small farms
  • Hand-cut orders

For a signature hand-selected American Wagyu porterhouse prime steak, click here.

Stock Quality: Omaha Steaks or Chicago Steak Company?

Chicago vs Omaha meat quality

Both claim to offer the best steaks, but we thought Chicago Steak Company took the win. One of the items we received was the filet mignon. It was good, tender, and nicely marbled. It went straight to our dining room.

We could tell the premium certified product difference. Omaha reviews show that they offer premium wet-aged meat cuts, but it didn’t quite compare in terms of tenderness. This may have something to do with the healthy aging process of the Chicago Steak Company.

Chicago's Aging Process

  • Top 3% marbled
  • Juicy and tender
  • Great buttery flavor
Omaha's Aging Process

  • Thinner
  • Grass grazing with lean cut
  • Smaller cuts

Shipping & Delivery

Chicago Steaks delivery

When we ordered hand-cut baby back ribs, angus beef cuts, T-bones, strip steaks, whole chicken, and prime rib from each website for a recent work barbecue, they all arrived with plenty of ice.

The meats are flash-frozen before shipping for 100% satisfaction guarantee.

The shipping costs for each delivery area averaged the same for both, with Chicago’s larger items being a few dollars more.

Both mail order steak companies pack their quality meats in boxes and use a reusable cooler container with dry ice.

With Chicago Steak Company delivery service, shipping time was slightly longer, depending on the shipping method. The other provider's delivery area is greater since it includes regions outside the US states.

Pricing & Plans

Omaha meat quality

In our Omaha Steaks reviews, we find the pricing for their meat selection to be generally slightly less than the other service.

We thought that the slight price tag difference was worth it for wider list. However, neither place offers a subscription meat delivery services.

Customers' feedback for Omaha Steaks meat delivery services state that it has a daily and monthly sale page.

Chicago Steak Company often runs promo codes, especially during the holiday season that include gifts and money savings deals on USDA prime meals, Angus beef, and sides.

Customer Support

When we originally placed an order with both providers, we set a delivery date that conflicted with a trip. We called both companies to change the date to the next day. Omaha’s customer service was even able to change our delivery date since the packaging had not been filled yet.

Based on our Chicago Steak Company review, Chicago’s customer rep offered to change it for us as well. Customer service experience for both of these meal delivery services has an above-average rating.

FAQs

What grade of meat does Omaha Steaks and Chicago Steak Company use?

Instead of labeling their products based on USDA's standards, Omaha Steaks created their own meat grade and referred to it as commodity beef or boxed beef. In comparison, Chicago Steak prides itself of USDA prime and choice selection.

How long will the Omaha and Chicago steaks last in the freezer?

When placed in the freezer, the steaks will last for around three to six months. All steaks are vacuum sealed and flash-frozen. This special packaging allows meat to be at the peak of its tenderness and keeps it tasty for up to three months. Both companies suggest not to thaw the steaks at room temperature.

How do I thaw my Chicago Steak and Omaha steaks?

Thaw your Omaha and Chicago steaks in the refrigerator and not at room temperature. This process will preserve both flavor and tenderness of the meats. Thawing usually takes around 12 hours for steaks, and until you're all set to cook them, do not remove the plastic wrapping.

Why are my Chicago steaks brown?

According to Chicago Steak Company, the meat turns brown during vacuum sealing. As soon as the meat is thawed, it will be exposed to oxygen and the red color may return. In addition, the company reminds the consumer that aged steak often has a darker color compared to fresh meat as a result of the dry aging process.

Chicago Steak or Omaha Steaks? We Choose…

While both mail-order companies claim to have the best steak, we think that Chicago Steak Company offers a better deal when it comes to the menu options and prices. They offer a wider list of beef that includes dry-aged steak.

But if you ask us, we recommend ButcherBox for our meats shipped week after week. We are quite impressed with how we always get the same great cut plus the best buttery taste every time we make an order.

You also get to curate your own subscription and have it delivered right to your doorstep, free of charge.

Butcher box package

Our #1 Recommendation

ButcherBox

  • Premium items
  • Regular promo codes and gift cards for savings
  • Large variety of options
  • Consistent flavor and fast shipping
Click For Best Price
payment icons

About the author