At Carnivore Style, our goal is to test every meat delivery service available. A friend of ours recently mentioned they placed an or with Mr Steak, and we should give them a try. For this Mr Steak review, we placed a few different orders to see if they would be a good option or if there is a better alternative.

What is Mr Steak?

types of meats

Mr Steak is an online meat delivery service that delivers high-quality steaks to your doorstep. They source all of their steaks from within a 250-mile radius of Omaha, Nebraska. Every local ranch that they partner with ensures that their cows are pasture-raised and finished on grain for the most marbling.

Mr Steak chooses USDA prime beef, which is the top 2 to 3% of beef that is hand-chosen for its texture and tenderness. They also offer choice beef as a less expensive alternative. All of the local ranchers ensure that their cows are raised humanely.

Pros
  • Offers USDA prime and choice
  • Curated meat boxes
  • Build your own box options
  • Currently offering free ground shipping
Cons
  • They only offer beef cuts

How Does Mr Steak Work?

Mr Steak lets you choose from their selection of USDA prime and choice beef. They do not require a subscription, but you cannot buy one steak at a time. You can choose from one of their curated boxes or build your own. Once you choose your box, Mr Steak will ship it within two days.

Other meat subscription services that deliver to your doorsteps:

What Are the Menu Options?

meat slices

The menu options at Mr Steak include USDA prime and choice beef cuts. Mr Steak offers almost every standard cut of beef, but they do not offer any specialty cuts such as Wagyu. All of their offerings are organic, non-GMO, and steroid free. If you’re looking for Wagyu we recommend you check out Snake River Farms.

Popular Menu Options:

  • Filet mignon
  • Ribeye
  • NY strip
  • Porterhouse
  • Brisket burgers

How is the Meat Quality & Sourcing Practice?

They only partner with local ranches that raise their cows humanely on pasture land. Mr Steak’s beef is above average compared to grocery stores. We thought it was on par with other meat delivery services such as ButcherBox.

Mr Steak Grills

grilled meat

Mr Steak offers both portable and patio grills in different sizes. The portable options come with 1 or 2 burners and use infrared technology.

Mr Steak patio grills use propane and come with 3, 4, or 5 burners. We found that Mr Steak grills were a bit more expensive compared to other brands.

 

Recommended Article: Top 5 Places To Buy Prime Steaks

Placing Your Order with Mr Steak

Mr Steak ships all orders with 2-day ground or express depending on your location. They ship orders out on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday. They are currently offering free ground shipping on all orders. The prices at Mr Steak are generally more expensive than grocery store prices.

At the time of this writing, Mr Steak is offering free ground shipping on all orders. They offer 5% off of $200, 10% off of $275, and 15% off of $350 or more on all beef boxes.

How Does the Order Arrive?

Your Mr Steak order will arrive in Green Cell Foam cooler that is made of compostable corn. It will dissolve under warm running water. They package all of their meat with dry ice so that it doesn’t thaw out while in transit.

Mr Steak recommends grilling all of their steaks on a hot grill with the lid open. We followed the How to Grill the Perfect Steak recipe for our first taste test, and it came out tender and juicy.

 

Mr Steak recommended marinating your steak for 45 minutes before you cook it. While you're at it, you can also use a smoker box or a vertical pellet smoker.

One Downside

One downside to Mr Steak is that they don’t offer an option to just purchase one or two steaks. Another downside is that they had a recent recall of some of their patio grill models. The fuel line and gauge were not mounted to the side of the grill. They have since offered a free repair kit.

 

Mr Steak Reviews & Online Ratings

After my careful review, I think that Mr Steak might be a good option for customers who want to purchase high-quality beef that will be delivered to their doors. According to TrustPilot, Mr Steak has an “excellent” review rating of 4.6 stars [1].

Mr Steak trustpilot review

Is Mr Steak Worth It?

After our testing, I think that Mr Steak is an adequate option for customers that want to switch up their beef cuts from the standard grocery store options.

But, if you're looking for wider meat selection, we highly recommend ButcherBox.

ButcherBox offers more than just your traditional premium beef in their subscription boxes. You also get a taste of quality poultry and seafood. We love how fast they deliver our orders, free of charge.

Butcher box package

Recommended Meat Service

ButcherBox

  • High-quality meat delivered right to your door
  • Humanely raised without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable meat orders available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of this month
Click For Best Price
payment icons

About the author