Mr Steak Review (2024 Upd) Everything You Need To Know

Timothy Woods
Published by Timothy Woods
Last Updated On: January 19, 2024

At Carnivore Style, our goal is to test every meat delivery service available. A friend of ours recently mentioned they placed an order with Mr Steak and said we should give them a try. For this Mr Steak review, we decided to place a few different orders to see if they would be a great meal option or if there is a better meat alternative. We'll share our verdict.

What is Mr Steak?

different cuts of meat in a plate, and Mr Steak logo

Mr Steak is an online meat delivery service that offers high-quality steaks to your doorstep. As per our review, the company chooses USDA prime beef, which is the top 2 to 3% of beef hand-selected for its texture and tenderness. Mr Steak also offers choice steaks as a less expensive alternative.

They source all of their meats and steaks from within a 250-mile radius of Omaha, Nebraska, also called the "Napa Valley of Beef." Every local ranch that Mr Steak partners with ensures that their cattle are pasture-raised and finished on grain for the most marbling. All of the local ranchers and companies ensure that their cows are raised humanely.

  • Offers USDA prime and choice
  • Curated steak boxes
  • Pasture-raised cattle
  • Build your own steak box options
  • Currently offering free ground shipping
  • They only offer beef cuts

How Does It Work?

Mr Steak works by letting you to choose from their selection of USDA prime and choice beef and steaks, and buy through one-off purchases. They do not require a steak subscription on their meats, but you cannot buy one item per box at a time. You can choose from one of their curated boxes or build your own meals. Once you choose your box and quantity, they will ship the items within two days.

Other subscription services that deliver to your doorsteps:

What Are the Menu Options?

close up image cooked meat slices in a plate

The menu options at Mr Steak include USDA prime and choice beef cuts. They offer almost every standard cut of beef, but they do not offer any specialty steaks like Wagyu. All of their offerings are organic, non-GMO, and non-steroid. We ordered flat iron steak, T-bone in ribeye, prime bone-in ribs, brisket burgers, cowboy steak, and New York strip steak for this review.

If you’re looking for Wagyu for Memorial Day, Father's Day, or just a weekend dinner, we recommend you check out Snake River Farms and Lobel's restaurant.

Popular Menu Options:

  • Filet mignon
  • Boneless Ribeye
  • Cowboy steak
  • Flat iron steak
  • Bone-in Ribeye
  • Kansas City strip
  • NY strip
  • Porterhouse
  • Brisket burgers

How is the Quality & Sourcing Practice at Mr Steak?

Mr. Steak only partners with local midwest ranches that raise their cows humanely on pasture land. Based on reviews, the beef is above average compared to grocery stores or any warehouse club, which is why many steakhouses get regular supplies from them. We thought the flavor they shared was on par with other services, such as ButcherBox meat delivery services.

Grilling Accessories

close up image of a beef patty getting grilled

Aside from quality meat cuts and steaks, Mr Steak also offers portable and patio iron pits in different sizes. The portable options come with 1 or 2 fire burners and use infrared technology.

These grilling accessories are good companions when you're thinking about preparing ribeyes, brisket blend burgers, or Kansas City burger patties with steak magic sauce.

The patio product uses propane and comes with 3, 4, or 5 heat burners. We found that the Mr Steak grill burner was a bit more expensive compared to other brands.

Placing Your Order

As per our Mr Steak review, Mr Steak ships all steaks with a 2-day ground or express depending on your location. They ship out on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday. We've talked with the customer service staff and learned that they are currently offering complimentary ground shipping on their food. The prices of the ribeye steaks are generally more expensive than grocery store prices.

At the time of this writing, the company is offering complimentary ground shipping on all steaks and strips so that you can get the most value for your money. They offer 5% off of $200, 10% off of $275, and 15% off of $350 or more on all boxes.

How Do the Items Arrive?

Based on our Mr Steak review, your items will arrive in Green Cell Foam cooler packaging that is made of compostable corn. It will dissolve under warm running water. They package all of their steaks with dry ice so that it doesn’t thaw out while in transit. Put the pack inside the freezer if not consumed immediately.

The company recommends grilling all of their animal produce on a hot pit with the lid open or with the use of grill mats to get a solid flavor and avoid flare-ups. We followed the How to Cook the Perfect Steak recipe for our first pack tasting. If you give it a head start, the boneless ribeye will come back tender and juicy. The grilled chicken burger came out big and with the perfect amount of fat and juices, too. We've also read some comments that recommend marinating it for 45 minutes before cooking.

One Downside

One downside is that Mr Steak doesn’t offer an option to purchase one or two products. Another problem is that they had a recent recall of some of their patio cooking pit grills. The fuel line and gauge were not well-mounted to the side of the pit. They have since offered a complimentary repair kit.

Reviews & Online Ratings

Based on our review, Mr Steak might make a good option for customers who want to purchase hand-selected high-quality meat products that will be delivered to their doors. That's the consensus we've seen on social media sites like Facebook and Twitter. According to TrustPilot, the company has an “excellent” rating of 4.6 stars [1].

Mr Steak trustpilot review

Mr. Steak vs. ButcherBox

Mr. Steak provides flexible ordering without a subscription requirement and sources meat locally from Omaha's "Napa Valley of Beef," while ButcherBox operates on a subscription basis with detailed transparency about its ethically sourced meats and offers free delivery on all orders with various delivery frequency options.

Still, I was impressed by how transparent ButcherBox is when it comes to its sourcing practices. They go into much more detail compared to Mr. Steak.

ButcherBox sources its meat from humanely raised, grass-fed beef without hormones or antibiotics, mostly from Australia, crate-free heritage pork with natural diets, organic free-range chicken, and sustainably harvested wild-caught seafood.

Mr. Steak offers ground or express delivery options, shipping on Monday through Wednesday to all U.S. states except Alaska and Hawaii, with a minimum order value of $94 and free shipping on orders over $175.

ButcherBox gets a huge plus for having free delivery on all orders. They also send an email with the tracking information. If you decide to continue with the subscription, you can choose to get a box every month, every six or eight weeks.

Is Mr Steak Worth It?

After our Mr Steak review and taste trial, we think that they provide an adequate experience for customers that want to switch up a piece of their beef cuts from the standard steakhouse or grocery store options.

But if you're looking for a wider selection, we highly suggest that you try ButcherBox.

ButcherBox provides more than just your traditional premium steaks in their subscription boxes. You also get a taste of restaurant-quality free-range organic poultry and wild-caught seafood. We love how fast they deliver our orders, free of shipping charge. You also get to curate your own box. Follow us for more info on online meat providers.

#1 Meat Delivery Service


butcher box cta
Meat Quality
Menu Options
  • Grass-fed and grass-finished beef delivered directly to your door
  • Without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of June
  • No organ meat
Was this article helpful?

About the author

Timothy Woods
CEO / Co-Founder
Timothy Woods holds a Kinesiology and Exercise Science degree from Jacksonville University and is CCC & GMU Certified. He's also the main man behind Carnivore Style. This food aficionado combines science and experience to spread the word about the carnivore lifestyle.
Learn more about our editorial policy

One thought on “Mr Steak Review
Is This a Good Option For You?

  1. The fire burners and use of infrared technology on the Mr. Steak accessories are not only sleek but durable. And the included iron pits keep it looking brand new. Highly recommend!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *