One of our chief complaints when buying meat from the supermarket is that it either lacks good flavor or is often too tough. But then one day we had a chat with one of our restaurant buddies, and he said something that stuck - he started getting quality, pasture-raised meat produce from Porter Road Butcher shop.

After placing a few orders from the company, my team thinks it’s time for a Porter Road review.

What Is Porter Road Butcher?

review of Porter Road

Porter Road Butcher was founded by James Peisker and Chris Carter in 2010. The two founders owned a catering business in Tennessee but kept running out of the right stock. Their solution was to begin sourcing and shopping their own meat from a Kentucky location facility and establishing a nice butcher shop in Nashville.

They eventually opened and already started out serving the local consumer and catering business. But, as word got out about their high-quality cuts of meat, they set up a website and began selling online as a meat delivery service. They've since become an online meat delivery provider selling good pre-made box options around the United States and expanding to delicious grass-fed, farm-raised meat, pork, chicken, and lamb.

Pros
  • Good portions and ample cuts
  • Excellent overall quality
  • Environmentally friendly meat sourcing
  • Allows individual purchase or you can subscribe
Cons
  • Limited options to choose from
  • No seafood category available

What Are The Menu Choices?

Upon looking at Porter Road's selection, you'll find it a bit more limited than some of the other virtual meat delivery service providers. The same goes for when you look at local grocery stores. However, they still offer your favorite portions and an ample choice of great cuts suitable for each cooking method or recipe, such as:

1. Beef

The company offers various cuts per pound of grain blend finished beef, including ground beef, marrow bone, chuck eye steak, blade steak, short ribs, filet mignon, and more. Tender steaks galore for your grilled recipes.

2. Chicken

You can find both whole chickens, as well as bone-in and boneless chicken breast and fresh chicken broth for easy cooking.

3. Pork

Porter Road offers great types and cuts, including pork butt, boneless pork chops, bone-in pork chop, country sausage, hand-cut pork steaks, half pork butt, breakfast sausage, and more. For the best kind of pork, check Kurobuta pork.

4. Lamb

You can also find a wide array of good lamb meat both online and at their Nashville meat shop. Some of the tender cuts you can buy include a pound or two of lamb shoulder, shank, steaks, and more.

Any Other Variety?

Even though they don't have a seafood category or some of the other specialty products like bison or venison, we can say that there sure is plenty of choices for your grilled beef, pork, and poultry recipes. Each cut is different, and you can find any produce to cook any way you like, especially if you want the flavor back to your recipe.

They have great cuts suitable for every type of cooking method imaginable. One of the main things we loved when we tried Porter Road was that we could have a different cut cooked each day. Good stuff.

How Is The Quality?

carve cow

The cut of meat you would get from the grocery store is usually high in fat and low in nutrients.

A lot of it is packed with hormones and sourced from a purveyor or provider that most likely isn’t raising their animals with care.

That's the main difference between Porter Road and traditional meat shops.

During our order review, we found that the quality was nothing less than excellent every time we ordered it straight to our door.

From local farms directly to your dinner table, their hand-cut steak, select ground beef, and other meaty delights always come back fresh. The taste and flavor were never inconsistent. Always flavorful, exactly how we like it.

Porter Road Meat Sourcing

Like many other online meat service providers, Porter Road's quality meat is at a much higher standard than what you would normally find in a grocery store or at meat shops.

According to their website, Porter Road sources all of its delicious meat from local farms near their processing plants in Kentucky and Tennessee.

The induction of antimicrobial-resistant bacteria and the disruption of normal human intestinal flora [from antibiotics in meat] are major concerns in terms of human health impact.

- Daejin Kang, Ministry for Food, Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries, South Korea

All of the local farms they work with practice environmentally friendly techniques. They do not rely on the use of hormones or antibiotics. Porter Road claims that all its select produce are pasture-raised, grass-fed, and free-range. They also avoid buying from people who operate mass factory farms or raise animals inhumanely.

Porter Road Pricing

Their pricing is a bit higher than your local shop or in the grocery store meat section. Due to the way they source their top produce, you'll see the amount per pound of many of its animal produce is a little pricey to match the quality and environmentally-friendly animal raising practices.

Their beef ranges between $8 for the cheapest cut to over $100 for whole chunks. Free-range chicken prices come close to $15 to over $26 for large whole chickens. Pork prices range close to $9 to over $30 for some cuts.

Subscription Boxes

Porter Road offers individual purchasing of their items, or you can also subscribe to their services in time. Their resource is new and allows you to customize your box completely so that you can get added popular options each month. All of the delicious animal produce comes from the Porter Road shop. You can also buy curated options that include:

quality meat

Butchers Choice Box - includes delicious steak, ground beef, bacon, and various other types of pork.

Best of Porter Road - this is a hand-selected great mix of their various types of juicy meat. It's suitable for adding to the grill, cooking with a sous vide, or throwing on a cast-iron skillet. Great to share with family and friends.

Grill Master - as the name implies, this option is full of top lamb, beef or pork that are better suited for grilling and slathering some salt, beer, BBQ sauce, or hot sauce on. For the best grilling experience, consider using a smoker box or Smoke Hollow at home.

Delivery & Packaging

Like many other companies, Porter Road packages its deliveries in environmentally friendly biodegradable packaging. They use a cornstarch-based foam when packing, which, according to the site, can be washed down the sink or used to help light your grill.

But unlike other companies that freeze and mail using dry ice packs, this enterprise doesn't freeze most of their beef to ensure freshness and taste. Since it might turn bad after a few hours, you really need to be at home when your order arrives. Get it into the fridge as soon as you can.

Porter Road Shipping

Porter Road ships to the 48 contiguous states in the United States. This excludes Alaska, Hawaii, and other remote territories of the country. When you make a purchase, they offer both standard and express shipping and provide free shipping on all orders over $100. All pasture-raised beef is shipped from either the Porter Road shop in Tennessee or their working facility.

There are stringent laws in place covering where beef can be shipped by mail, so they have the same area as other subscription services. (2)

Porter Road Storage

The company recommends the best way to store all fresh produce. As soon as you get your package, get it into the refrigerator. Storage should be short-term to ensure the best flavor and taste. According to their site, a small piece of beef that is frozen runs the risk of becoming damaged due to ice formation (3). As ice forms, the beef hardens, and the crystals cut through the fiber of the meat itself.

It is recommended that you freeze or consume poultry within four days, pork within five days, and beef within ten days unless it is ground.

Customer Support

beef Porter Road

Porter Road is unique because it has a shop in Nashville, as well as a considerable online presence. With this in mind, they have two ways of providing great customer support - email and phone. This means that with just a click of a button, you can call whenever you need assistance, whether it's helping with one of your orders or questions about the up and coming products.

You can also find lots of web reviews from customers who have had really positive experiences with the service and specifically mention customer support as a huge plus.

Downsides of Porter Road

While there are numerous upsides to Porter Road and its delivery, there are two main drawbacks:

The first is that, while they have a large variety of cuts you can buy, there isn't as much to choose from as far as other types of meat go. You'll see that some other online companies offer new and really unique items, such as bison, elk, venison, and several kinds of seafood. What they do offer is excellent, but having a bit more variety would make you see all the difference.

FAQs

Is Porter Road cheaper than Costco?

Not likely. The prices at Porter Road are a bit higher than Costco or any local shop, for that matter. This is due to the company's sourcing and quality control practices.

Why isn’t my Porter Road steak shipped frozen?

Some of Porter Road's meat are shipped frozen, including sausage and ground beef. However, most of their meats aren't because they want to preserve the freshness of the meat as much as possible. They believe that freezing may cause chemical changes which affect the product.

Is dry-aged Porter Road beef better than grocery meat?

Yes. Dry-aged beef tastes better than grocery meat because drying allows the meat to naturally tenderize for a more concentrated flavor. The meat that you buy from the supermarket or grocery is rarely dried. Check more about dry-aged here.

Is Porter Road meat certified organic?

The small farms that Porter Road works with have no official certification, but with their strict farming guidelines, they claim to almost always beat even the minimum organic standards. They like to call it "beyond organic."

Our Verdict on Porter Road Butcher

To be frank, we were quite happy with Porter Road Butcher - we think it's a good choice to try. We like how Porter Road sources all of its products humanely and that they work with local providers as opposed to large cattle farms.

Although we received our orders without any issues and delays, we think that the high-quality meat cuts from ButcherBox still have the best flavor and consistent taste. We love how they offer a wide selection on their beef and other menu options.

Get that fresh pork on your fork and make your day.

Butcher box package

Recommended Meat Service

ButcherBox

  • High-quality meat delivered right to your door
  • Humanely raised without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable meat orders available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of this month
Click For Best Price
payment icons

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *