Timothy Woods
Published by Timothy Woods
Last Updated On: September 21, 2021

If you haven’t tried a meat delivery service that brings you high-quality and humanely-raised meats right at your doorstep, you haven’t lived.

Not long ago, we came across ButcherBox, a delivery service company that claims to do just that. So brace yourselves, a Butcher Box review is coming.

And a word to the wise - it’s going to be a meaty article.

What Is ButcherBox?

Butcher Box is a meat delivery service from Boston, MA, offering subscription boxes that contain various types of ingredients, such as ground beef, pork chops, sirloin steak, and whole chicken.

Their quality of meat cuts is reputed to have exceptional taste and nutrition, particularly the all-time popular grass-fed beef, which is also grass-finished.

They also carry free-range organic chicken, heritage-breed pork, and wild-caught seafood.

ButcherBox offers quality pork, beef, chicken, and seafood that you don't normally find at local grocery stores other than Whole Foods, albeit at premium prices per pound. You can also save money by ordering in bulk and setting up a regular subscription plan.

Pros
  • Organic grass-fed beef
  • Humanely-raised heritage breed pork
  • Free-range organic chicken
  • Flexible proportion and delivery frequency
  • Good pricing when buying in bulk
Cons
  • No organ meat

Additional Benefits

Based on our Butcher Box review, we think ButcherBox certainly does live up to the company's high-quality meat claims.

The free-range organic chicken is particularly tasty, and the difference between grass-fed and “industrial” beef is quite noticeable.

ButcherBox tastes better than most of the meats anyone would typically get via several grocery stores.

Butcher Box Quality & Sourcing Methods

Butcher Box sources from trusted ranches and dedicated local farmers with a focus on sustainability and raising the animals humanely.

The high-quality beef from ButcherBox mostly hails from Australia, while their heritage-breed pork, wild-caught seafood, and free-range organic chicken are sourced from North America, where ethical practices are encouraged.

In our honest Butcher Box review, we have to say that our personal experiences have been mostly positive. So far, we have no reason to believe they ship anything but quality meat in each box.

ButcherBox only uses certified sources of grass-fed beef, organic free-range chicken, wild-caught seafood, and heritage pork.

Your meat and seafood are less likely to be full of herbicides, and will not contain antibiotics [1] or added hormones [2].

How Does ButcherBox Compare to Costco & Other Wholesale Corporations?

female in a grocery store thinking

"It is important to me and my community that our animal protein sources are naturally and responsibly raised and grass fed. For this reason, I trust and recommend ButcherBox."
- Melissa Hartwig, Co-Founder of the Whole 30

We know that many love the Costco store because they do not fall short on offering healthy staples.

Costco and Whole Foods are undoubtedly inexpensive but the quality of the meat is not the same.

Costco is not necessarily 100% grass-fed, grass-finished beef, whereas Butcher Box is.

And if it isn’t 100% grass-finished cattle, then it's loaded with unhealthy fat per pound and plenty of fillers from corn and soy at the end of production - a practice that limits the better health benefits, proteins, and vitamins you would otherwise get from pasture-raised, free-range chickens, and beef.

Website Experience

man on a laptop searching for meat

When we first clicked on the Butcher Box website, we were met with an offer too good to refuse.

Our favorite words “get them for free” were highlighted in red. Once we clicked the button, we were redirected to a page that made my mouth water.

If we signed up right there and then, we would receive 6 burgers, 8 hot dogs, and 3lbs of chicken breasts inside our first box, free of charge.

Along with choosing from 24 meat preparations, we’d also get a few extra meals thrown in for free. Of course, we immediately signed up and excitedly ordered our very first box.

Butcher Box Menu & Plans

grilling sausage and a fresh pork meat

The first box we tried for this Butcher Box review had quite limited Butcher Box meat options.

Over time, we got bored with frequently ordering top sirloin steak tips, beef tips, pork loin, ground beef, burgers, boneless pork chops, top round, quality roasts, and a little heritage breed package of bacon on the side.

Over the years, their offer of meats has improved based on demand, and if you select their custom box, you have numerous options.

Here are a few examples of their menu options:

  • New York strip steaks
  • Pork loin
  • Chicken tenders
  • Chicken breast
  • Top sirloin steaks
  • Ribeyes

 

  • Chuck roast
  • Whole Turkey (seasonal)
  • Lamb (seasonal)
  • Heritage pork chops and bacon
  • Sausages (breakfast and Italian)

 

  • Baby-back and St. Louis Style Ribs
  • Sockeye Salmon
  • Uncured bacon
  • Boneless pork chops
  • Grass fed Ground beef
  • Ground sirloin

The main thing a real carnivore might still be missing is organ meat. But other than that, there’s a fairly good selection of grass-fed cuts of meat to cover your meal plans.

Types of Meat You Can Have Delivered

  • Mixed box - It can be a mix of grass-finished beef, heritage breed pork, free-range organic chicken, and marine produce. If you wish to learn which meat delivery box we think is the best, visit this link.
  • Curated All-beef option box - This mixed Butcher box beef option contains a varied selection from ground beef to filet mignons.
  • Curated Beef and pork box - Provides about a 50/50 split in weight per pound between pork products and cuts of beef.
  • Curated Beef and chicken box - Provides about a 50/50 split in weight per pound between grass-fed beef and chicken tenders or chicken breasts.
  • Custom box - Allows you to handpick your meat cuts and a couple of add-ons, like bacon, ground beef, and ground pork. Neat, isn’t it?
  • Gift Box - ButcherBox gift boxes include Game Day Box, Steak Lovers' Box, ButcherBox Favorites, ButcherBox Mixed Box, Wild Salmon Box, and ButcherBox Beef & Chicken.

The first 4 ButcherBox options are pre-selected, meaning you can’t pick the humanely-raised, high-quality meats you receive. The Custom Box is the only alternative where you can make a selection to your liking. At Carnivore Style, we would get customized packaging each month because we like to prepare different steak or chicken breast recipes.

You can also choose between two box sizes:

  1. 8 to 11 lbs box - Suitable for couples and small families.
  2. 16 to 22 lbs box - Suitable for families with 4-5 members or people with enough storage room in their freezer.

For larger families or people who rely on the whole chicken, chicken breasts, boneless pork tenderloin, steak, pork butt, ground pork, and grass-fed beef combo deals as their only source of protein throughout the week, ordering the Big ButcherBox option may be the best solution.

How Does ButcherBox Work?

Butcher Box un frozen meat

You can get your hands on good quality meat in a fairly simple three-step ordering process:

  1. Build your box - You can pick and buy their pre-curated shipment boxes, or customize your own box.
  2. Get your packages - Your cuts of meat reach your door still frozen from shipping, carefully packed in an insulated box, and free of charge.
  3. Defrost, cook, and dig in - No need to explain things here. Just fill your plate.

How Much Does ButcherBox Cost?

woman in glasses holding some cash while contemplating

You can select a classic box for just over $100, which includes 8-11 pounds, for roughly 24 meal preparations.

Or you could get a classic big box that costs around twice as much and contains 16 to 22 pounds that is equivalent to 48 meals.

The small custom option has a price point of about $150 with 9 to 14 pounds of meat. A big custom box is close to $270, which has 18 to 26 pounds of grass-fed meats, making it one of the best organic meat delivery options.

Breakdown Of The Price

  1. Custom Small Box - 9-14 lbs for $4.97 average per meal (per pound)
  2. The Mixed Box - 8.5 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average (per pound)
  3. The Beef & Pork Box - 8 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average per meal (per pound)
  4. The Beef & Chicken Box - 8.5 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average per meal (per pound)
  5. The All-Beef Box - 8 - 10 lbs for $5.38 average (per pound)

5 Tips to Afford ButcherBox Even On a Tight Budget

person inserting a penny in a piggy bank

Since ButcherBox grass-fed meat doesn't come cheap, for this ButcherBox review we came up with a list of strategies you can try to get the most value for the price.

1. Choose your box wisely.

The custom ButcherBox is the most costly option so unless you’re picky, choose other grass-finished beef boxes instead. If you do order a custom box, make sure you only choose meat cuts that can give you a great deal per pound.

2. Check membership deals.

Always be on the lookout for special offers and deals for members. As members, we’ve had the chance to get several tasty promotions, like the ButcherBox bacon and ground beef for life.

3. Order cuts of beef that you can’t get anywhere.

If your local store offers the same quality at a lower price, why order the same stuff? In our case, we have difficulty finding high-quality, grass-fed, and grass-finished beef cuts, so that’s what we keep ordering from ButcherBox.

4. Use the discount codes.

ButcherBox offers discount codes that you can apply to your order if you refer someone to order from them. If you sign up for the email newsletter, you'll be at the front of the line for exclusive promotions, discounts, and perks.

5. Compare prices.

If you compare prices, you can see that many supermarkets have more expensive offers per pound compared to ButcherBox. Aside from saving a few bucks, you get to enjoy free delivery right to your doorstep.

Shipping

Butcherbox sample in a porch

ButcherBox has a very straightforward shipping plan.

The first month you start your service, they will get your meat to you within 3-7 days after ordering. My experience was extremely positive; the package arrived three days after I placed my order.

As long you continue with your subscription, ButcherBox will ship so that your next package arrives precisely when you want it to.

And one of my favorite aspects of the service is that shipping is always free of charge.

How Does Butcher Box Arrive?

meat vacuumed in a plastic

To ensure nothing gets spoiled during transport, the Butcher Box meat packaging is transported to your front door frozen and vacuumed packed in a freezer bag with dry ice in a 100% curbside recyclable box.

You can either put the meat in a freezer or defrost it. After the meat is defrosted, it’s best to cook it straight away; don’t refreeze it for another day.

Delivery Frequency

Lastly, you can also set the frequency of your ButcherBox meat box delivery - how many times a month or year you want to order.

If you’re on a strict carnivore diet, you'll need to order a big packaging for any meat recipe.

5 Reasons Why Butcher Box Might Be Worth It

Product image for ButcherBox

At Butcher Box, the taste of high-quality meat is really worth the price. It's a palatable experience and having made a few orders ourselves and reading countless customer reviews, we’ve boiled down all benefits to the following 3 reasons for this ButcherBox review.

1. Value For Money

A very important benefit we want to mention in this ButcherBox review is the value for money you get with each box, given their high-quality prime meat. Y

ou can regularly treat yourself with reasonably priced meats like grass-fed ground beef, whole chicken, seafood, and pork by subscribing or ordering in bulk.

After all, life is too short to eat bad steaks or strip steak tips.

2. Convenience

man with stock and packages of food in his car trunk

Another thing worth mentioning in our ButcherBox review is the convenience you get. Aside from the lower costs, having your food delivered to your door beats visiting a local grocery store anytime.

Our first big order came without issues - and we got to enjoy servings of free bacon and breakfast sausage. Great, indeed.

Your preferred box is shipped 3 to 6 days after they've charged your credit card.

You'll also get an email with a tracking number that contains the approximate delivery time. ButcherBox orders are fulfilled by either FedEx or UPS, depending on where you live.

3. Customer Service

We also wanted to share some information about the customer service in our ButcherBox review.

We've only had to deal with a customer service representative twice.

The first time we needed to delay the shipments for one day as we were unexpectedly away from home. The second instance was due to a minor issue on the delivered amount that was immediately rectified.

In both situations, we were impressed with their customer service compared to other meat services. Based on honest reviews, many people love Butcher Box because of how they deal with their clients.

4. Sourcing

farm with cows and chicken

ButcherBox obtains its meat from trusted partners who show dedication and passion for the farming industry.

They only work with farmers who follow specific rules and have their facilities inspected regularly by the USDA.

This way, only the highest quality meat is shipped to you.

ButcherBox specifically sources each type of meat to meet stringent criteria:

  • Beef - only 100% grass-fed and finished cattle that are humanely and pasture-raised are approved. No hormones or antibiotics are given to these animals.
  • Pork - only pigs raised crate-free are accepted, and they must have been given only 100% vegetarian feed without antibiotics or hormones.
  • Chicken - all birds must be raised free-range with only USDA-certified organic feed. They must also be Global Animal Partnership (GAP 3) certified.
  • Seafood - must be wild-caught and sustainably harvested. No artificial additives or colorings are permitted.

5. Taste

I don't know anyone who would argue that meat sourced ethically is not the best tasting meat available, and ButcherBox does not disappoint in this area.

I have tried their beef, chicken, pork, and seafood, and every single item was of the highest quality.

Although it is hard to pick out my favorites, I have to admit that bacon was absolutely to die for. It had just the right salty flavor and the perfect amount of fat and lean.

When it came to the beef, the sirloin was impeccable and almost melted in my mouth. Although it had less fat than a conventionally raised steak, the flavor and juiciness were beyond comparison.

Meat Company Alternatives

There are some alternative options to ButcherBox that you may want to consider.

Moink

logo and meat of moink meat

First, Moink is another company that provides high-quality, ethically-raised, grass-fed beef, lamb, pork, and wild-caught seafood.

It does not have the number of meat or box options that ButcherBox does, but it certainly does give you tasty meat.

Omaha Steaks

logo and meat of omaha steaks

Omaha Steaks is another business that will ship high-quality steak, prime rib, and more right to your front door.

They have a great selection of meat - perhaps the best available on the market.

However, Omaha Steaks does not ethically source its meat, and so you may end up eating more hormones or antibiotics than you might want.

US Wellness Meats

logo and meat of us wellness meat

Finally, US Wellness Meats is a worthy competitor to ButcherBox.

It offers specialty items such as organ meats, dairy, and pet food. It also acts more like a store in that you order exactly what you want.

However, it does not offer the convenience of a subscription nor, in my opinion, the tastiness of ButcherBox meats.

Happy Customer Reviews

Butcher Box happy customers

 

happy customers from Butcher Box

real customer testimonial and review

 

testimonials from two people

FAQs

How Long Can a Butcher Box Stay Outside on the Front Porch?

According to the company, your Butcher Box order can stay on the front porch for about 6 to 8 hours. It’s packaged using dry ice to maintain a constant temperature. However, it also depends on the time of the year and direct sunlight exposure.

Is Butcher Box Less Expensive Than Grocery Stores?

No, Butcher Box is not less expensive than grocery stores. However, given the product quality, texture, and convenience of having fresh organic meats delivered to your doorstep, it is worth it.

Does Butcherbox Have Fish?

Yes, ButcherBox has fish available to order as add-ons. At present, the seafood shopping choice is limited to wild-caught salmon and scallops (depending on the season and availability).

Can You Skip Months With the Butcherbox Subscription Service?

Yes, you can skip months with the ButcherBox subscription. You can delay or pause the service every other month or for up to 6 months without any extra cost or fees. Make sure you do this before your next order or prior to billing.

Is Butcherbox Cheaper Than Costco?

No, ButcherBox isn’t cheaper than Costco. Given the top-notch meat quality and intricate product preparation, it comes as no surprise that ButcherBox will cost you more than Costco. However, you should take into account their free delivery service.

Is Butcherbox Cheaper Than Whole Foods?

No, Butcher Box isn’t cheaper than Whole Foods. The high-quality meat comes from grass-fed and grass-finished animals and takes a longer time to cultivate. Hence, it may be more expensive to produce within the industry.

How Often Does Butcher Box Deliver?

Butcher Box delivers orders according to your requested frequency, which can be every week, every month, or every other month.

Does Butcherbox Accept EBT?

No, ButcherBox doesn’t accept EBT cards at this time due to COVID-19 regulations, and they do not accept PayPal either. However, this could change at a later date.

How Long Does It Take to Ship My Butcherbox Order?

It takes about 3 to 6 business days to ship your ButcherBox order. This mainly depends on two things - your volume of orders and your location.

Is Butcher Box Worth Trying Out?

After this thoughtful and honest Butcher Box review, we believe ButcherBox is definitely worth trying out.

One of the main highlights is the good selection of high-quality meat. In our opinion, meat raised the right way always has a better taste, so it's a no-brainer there, and the best benefit of all is the affordability of their subscription package.

Not only do they give you the option to curate your product box with all manner of savory items, but it will also be shipped to your front door, free of charge.

And considering that we don't need to visit the grocery store during a Coronavirus pandemic whenever we feel like getting grass-finished beef - we'd say that's one huge plus.

Butcher box package

ButcherBox

#1 Meat Delivery Service

  • Grass-fed and grass-finished beef delivered directly to your door
  • Without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of September
Click For Best Price
payment icons

About the author

40 thoughts on “ButcherBox Review
Is It a Good Deal? Plans, Pricing & More

  1. Nice one, Timothy! I tried their Butcher Box custom box one time, and boy, the cuts were enormous! It was worth a couple of days’ pay, man, but it was worth every penny!

    1. Hello, Mary Ann! Nope, you don’t have to order every week. The delivery frequency is totally flexible. You’ll get your box as often as you want. It’s really easy to make adjustments. But you have to take note that any changes you’ve made will go into effect only on the next scheduled order. They do have the option for immediate adjustments on both the bill date and the delivery frequency. Hope that helps!

  2. We love the free bacon! My 5-year old son is always excited to do the unboxing as soon as our order arrives. We rarely go out now, and the delivery system is very convenient for my family and I. We get good quality every single time. We are happy (and loyal) customers!

  3. This is some solid review, man! I just ordered the custom box, and I’m expecting it to arrive within the week, just in time for our weekly cookout sesh with the in-laws. I sure hope the meats are as good as what you said. This is exciting!

    1. Hold your horses, Harry! You’re in for the most mouthwatering experience of all time. We’ve been following ButcherBox since they opened up, and they never disappoint every single time.

  4. I don’t like going out of the house very much nowadays, and I’m looking for a good meat delivery service to order our weekly fix. I’ve heard good things about Butcher Box, and I’d like to try. What items do you suggest I start with?

    1. Great choice, Emily! ButcherBox offers grass-fed beef – all high-quality and healthy stuff! We suggest you try their mixed box first, so you get all chicken, beef, and pork options. Keep in touch and let us know how it went!

  5. Hey, Timothy! Just wondering. Do I really need to be home for the delivery? I mean, what if I need to go out for a quick run or something? I’m not really sure how these meat deliveries work. I can see by your review that you’re an expert on these things. Am I right?

    1. Hola, Clara Sue! Yes, I am your expert when it comes to meat deliveries (haha!). And no, you don’t need to wait all day at home for your ButcherBox order. You’ll get an email from their staff when your order has arrived. However, we recommend that you retrieve your box within 6 to 8 hours as soon as they arrive at your doorstep. Don’t waste good meat!

  6. We usually get our meat from Kroger or Trader Joe’s since we are on a super tight weekly budget. As much as possible, we also wait till there are markdowns on meats and other grocery items. While we think Butcher Box is really expensive, we sometimes like splurging, and BB is our go-to mail-order steak pros.

    1. Aww! That’s sweet, Penelope! We like our meats healthy and of premium quality. Yup, you get inexpensive cuts from the grocery store, but the taste is nowhere close to ButcherBox steaks.

      1. Exactly! We also like our burgers juicy and tender. My mom and I are saving small portions of our pay each week so that we can order from ButcherBox every two months or so.

    1. Hey Nicholas! They actually do, although it’s a seasonal cut just like whole turkeys. However, new cuts are available to active members only. Either that or you can have it as an add-on. We’ve heard they’re sourcing new products, too, so we’ll have to wait and see what’s next on the list. We’ll keep you posted, though!

  7. I just wanted to share my amazing experience with ButcherBox. One time I had an emergency, and as I was going out the front door, my ButcherBox delivery arrived. I immediately took it inside and left it on the counter. I got home around 5 to 6 hours later, and lo and behold! The meats were still frozen! The packaging is really good.

    1. That’s one great story to share, Samantha! Thanks! We’ve also experienced that once or twice in the past, and yes, you’re right! Everything’s well-packaged, so we’re not worried at all.

  8. My buddies and I ordered the mixed box last month. The strip steaks came out really good after cooking, but the pork tenderloin was just okay, in my opinion.

    1. Hey, Randolph! ButcherBox is a subscription service for meat deliveries, so you can’t make one-off purchases. However, members can either delay or stop their membership at any time before the next order is billed. It’s also effortless to change your box type and shipping frequency. BTW, they have a limited special offer for new members now – free turkey!

  9. I’m a ButcherBox member for over a year now, I think. We like them, the meats are good, the delivery is always on time, and so far, I haven’t had any problem with thawed meat or anything like that. But I think their customer service could use a bit of work—just some miscommunication issues I’ve encountered sometimes.

    1. Hey, Cole! Thanks for sharing this, man! We’ll try to reach out to their staff and see what we can come up with. We’ll update the review as soon as we get some info.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *