As a carnivore dieter, I usually encounter challenges when it comes to sourcing your meat. I struggle to find a grocery store with the right and consistent quality meat and get all the meat you need at a reasonable price.

More often than not, you’ll be able to satisfy one of these two, which often means that you end up having to increase your grocery budget. Unless, of course, you’re happy to risk health issues by buying lower-quality meat sources.

I’ve had some experience with meal delivery services for keto and paleo diets in the past, so I was interested to see whether I could get everything on my meat shopping list shipped as well.

As it turns out, this issue may be addressed, as long as you tweak the box options in the right way. Let me explain in this post my ButcherBox Review.

What Is ButcherBox?

ButcherBox is a meat delivery service offering subscription boxes that contain varying amounts and types of meat. The important thing to note is that the meat quality is claimed to be of high quality, as the beef is grass-fed, the free-range chicken, and the pork is a humanely raised heritage breed.

They offer quality standards that you would be able to find at Whole Foods stores, but usually at premium prices. With ButcherBox, you’re able to take advantage of lower prices by ordering in bulk and setting up a regular subscription plan.

This brings me to the next question...

How Does ButcherBox Work?

butcher box reviews

ButcherBox works based on choosing from a selection of different meat boxes to suit your meal plan. They provide options where you can pick the amount of meat you require and the frequency of the shipping.

Check out what they offer.

Available ButcherBox Plans

The first thing you do is pick the types of meat you want to have delivered.

  • Mixed Box: This box is a random mix of grass-fed beef, pork, free-range chicken, and fish with various cuts.
  • All Beef Box: Contains a varied selection from ground beef to filet mignons.
  • Beef and pork box: Provides about a 50/50 split in weight between the two products.
  • Beef and chicken box: Provides about a 50/50 split in weight between both types of meat.
  • Custom Box: Allows you to handpick the types of meat.

Size

The company offers two sizes of boxes:

  1. 1
    8 to 11 lbs box: suitable for individuals and small families
  2. 2
    16 to 22 lbs box: suitable for families or if you have a large freezer

Choose Some Add-Ons

This is a great way to get some extras every month with some fish; some specialty products are regularly on-hand.

Delivery Frequency

The last thing you need to decide on is how often you like to receive a delivery. If you’re only eating meat on a strict carnivore diet, then choosing one of the larger boxes may be needed every week or two.

ButcherBox Pros And Cons

person slicing Butcher Box meat

In this section of my post, I would like to highlight the main benefits and a couple of negatives that I have noted.

First of all, I have found that quality does live up to the claims.

The organic chicken is tasty, and you can tell the difference in the grass-fed beef (yes, I did do a taste test with some “industrial” beef).

What I liked the most about their service is the convenience, and the time I can save. Also, the fact that it seemed to work out cheaper than any grocery store I was using. That was the case with the mixed box and custom box.

Benefits

  • Grass-fed beef
  • Humanely raised Heritage breed pork [1]
  • Free-range chicken
  • Flexible sizes and delivery frequency
  • Good pricing when buying in bulk

Downsides

  • True carnivore dieters would still need to source organ meat
  • Some people would like to see more fish options

On the downside, while there are many kinds of cuts to choose from, you won’t find organ meat. If you like having some occasional fish from time to time, you may be limited.

What Do You Get?

In each package, you get a selection of randomly chosen meats or a specific selection that you enter.

The first time I tried the services in June 2018, the cuts you can choose from were still limited.

This meant I would easily get bored with having strip steak and roasts.

However, there have been quite a few changes, and you can get a pretty good choice of cuts of meat, which might help with recipe inspiration.

Here are a few examples of what’s on offer:

Person delivering Butcher Box
  • New York strip steaks
  • Pork tenderloin
  • Chicken tenders
  • Chicken breasts
  • Top sirloin steaks
  • Ribeyes
  • Chuck roast
  • Heritage pork chops and bacon
  • Sausages
  • Ribs
  • Salmon
  • Boneless pork

As I said above, the main thing a real carnivore might miss is the organ meat, but other than that, there’s a good selection of products to cover every meal.

How Much Does ButcherBox Cost Per Month?

ButcherBox costs $129 per month for the smaller classic box and $238 for the big one. The classic box includes 8-11 pounds that can be used for 24 meal preparations, while the big box contains 16 to 22 pounds that is equivalent to 48 meals.

Now, I also have to say that you can adjust the shipping time often, so the price is actually per delivery.

I saw some reviews from carnivore dieters who receive a big custom box every week. Just keep in mind that you’d still like to have a good bit of freezer space to store it all.

If you’re going through that much meat, then the convenience of not having to go to a Whole Foods store or local butcher once a week is worth considering.

Here is the Pricing Breakdown:

  • Custom Box: 9-14 lbs for $4.97 average per meal
  • The Mixed Box: 8.5 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average per meal
  • The Beef & Pork Box: 8 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average per meal
  • The Beef & Chicken Box: 8.5 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average per meal
  • The All Beef Box: 8 - 10 lbs for $5.38 average per meal

The Quality Of the Meat

My personal experience has been positive, and I have no reason to believe that ButcherBox ships anything but quality meat. That's why I did this review to share my positive experiences.

They only use certified sources of high quality grass-fed and grass-finished beef, free-range organic chicken, and heritage pork. This also means that your meats are less likely to be full of herbicides, antibiotics [2], and hormones [3]. 

I found a lot of reviews by professional bloggers and foodies who would seem to agree with this.

It is important to me and my community that our animal protein sources are naturally and responsibly raised and fed. For this reason, I trust and recommend ButcherBox.
- Melissa Hartwig, Co-Founder of the Whole 30

Is ButcherBox Worth It?

Person slicing salmon meat

Yes, in my opinion, ButcherBox is worth it. The products are worth spending some or most of your food budget for high-quality meats. Having used the service on a regular basis and read through countless customer reviews, I’ve brought it down to the following 3 reasons.

1 - Value For Money

Whether you really like to regularly treat yourself to some high-quality prime meat or just would like a reasonably priced source of grass-fed ground beef, when you order in bulk, you do tend to get better value. 

I personally still want to choose and look for good deals at my local butcher and supermarket, but it’s rarely beaten on value. 

2 - Convenience

Having your food delivered to your door makes life so much easier. My first big order was delivered without any hassle that's when I knew how really convenient this would be. 

Unless you have a really strict meal plan, it's also nice to join with the mixed subscription as an option to get a regular surprise of different products in a box. 

During the first order with ButcherBox, I found out you can choose from a lot of options.

3 - Customer Service

I've only had to deal with a customer service representative twice. Once, because I really needed to delay the shipping day as I was unexpectedly away from home. The other time was due to a minor issue on the delivered amount that was immediately rectified. In both situations, I was impressed.

Who Should Consider Trying Out ButcherBox?

roast chicken on roasting pan in oven

While I personally fall into the first category below, there really are a few other types of people who could take advantage of the service.

Carnivore Dieters

As already mentioned, having a reliable source of good meat at an affordable price could make quite a difference to a carnivore dieter's health, budget, and enjoyment. 

Busy Families

Shopping and choosing food is really a struggle for busy families. If you want to save some money and time by not having to worry about going to the grocery, then it could be a step in the right direction.

Anyone Planning A BBQ Party

If you want to plan a party or choose to serve BBQ for a lot of people, then you can get all you need with one of the once-off custom packages.

Where Do You Order?

smiling man using tablet ordering Butcher Box

The one and only place you can order is on the company website.

Alternatively, you could call to place your order. A few reviews and comments that I saw suggested that this might be a good way to get some ordering tips.

One tip I also want to give you is to come up with a list of meals and recipes that you regularly make and aim to order for those.

Over the coming months, you could then start switching things around with one option to some new ideas.

Positive Reviews

Butcher Box Happy customers
Butcher Box Satisfied Customer reviews
Butcher Box Positive consumer reviews
Butcher Box real feedback from satisfied clients

ButcherBox FAQs

How long can it stay outside on the front porch?

How is the ButcherBox meat shipped?

Is ButcherBox cheaper than grocery stores?

Does ButcherBox have fish?

How long does it take to ship?

Can you skip months with the service?

Is ButcherBox cheaper than Costco?

Where is ButcherBox meat from?

Is ButcherBox cheaper than Whole Foods?

Is ButcherBox meat frozen?

How often does ButcherBox deliver?

Is ButcherBox Worth Trying Out?

Yes, I believe ButcherBox is worth trying out, even if it doesn’t become your primary source of all your main ingredients.

I would also encourage you to read some of the reviews on the official site. 

For me, the attraction is the good selection of grass-fed meat, which I tend to eat the most when I go through my carnivore cycle.

Try out one of the mixed boxes and let us know in social media how it worked out for you.

#1 Meat Delivery Service

ButcherBox

  • High-quality meat delivered right to your door
  • Humanely raised without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of March

Timothy Woods
Follow me

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *