If you haven’t tried a meat delivery service that brings you high-quality meats from local farms right at your doorstep, you haven’t lived.

Not long ago, we came across ButcherBox, a delivery service company that claims to do just that. So brace yourselves, a Butcher Box review is coming.

And a word to the wise - it’s going to be a meaty article.

What Is ButcherBox?

Butcher Box reviews

ButcherBox is a meat delivery service from Boston, MA, offering subscription boxes that contain various types of ingredients, such as ground beef, pork chops, and naturally-raised chicken. Their quality of meat cuts is reputed to have exceptional taste, particularly the all-time popular beef, which is 100% grass-fed and antibiotic-free. The free-range chicken and the pork comes from the right heritage breeds, which are humanely raised on family-run farms by local farmers.

The Butcher Box offers quality standards that you don't normally find at grocery stores other than Whole Foods, albeit at premium prices per pound. You’re also able to take better advantage of lower prices by ordering the right bulk and setting up access to a regular subscription plan.

  • Organic grass-fed beef
  • Humanely-raised Heritage breed pork
  • Free-range chicken
  • Flexible sizes and delivery frequency
  • Good pricing when buying in bulk
  • No organ meat or offal
  • Some people would like to see more seafood options

Additional Benefits

Based on our experience, we think ButcherBox certainly does live up to the company's quality claims. The free-range organic chicken is particularly tasty, and you can know the difference in the grass-fed beef as well (yes, we already cross-taste-tested it with some “industrial” beef).

Also, we like the convenience of the subscription model service. It helps us save time and effort. We particularly enjoyed trying the mixed box - and with the premium quality taste of the cuts we get in one right serving, Butcher Box tastes better than most of the meats anyone would typically get via several grocery stores.

Butcher Box Quality & Sourcing Methods

Butcher Box sources from trusted ranches and dedicated local farmers that take care of free-range animals that are grass-fed and finished. The high-quality beef mostly hails from Australia, while their organic pork and free-range organic chicken are sourced from North America.

If my team and I were going to give one right and honest review, we have to say that our personal experiences have been mostly positive this time. In a way, we know it's easy to like them back. So far, we think we have no reason to believe that they ship anything but quality items in each box.

They only use certified sources of grass-fed and finished beef, free-range chicken, and heritage pork. This also means that your meats are less likely to be full of herbicides, antibiotics [1], and hormones [2].

We also read review after review by professional bloggers and online foodies who are going to agree with this. Here's an example:

How Does ButcherBox Compare to Costco & Other Wholesale Corporations?

"It is important to me and my community that our animal protein sources are naturally and responsibly raised and grass fed. For this reason, I trust and recommend ButcherBox."
- Melissa Hartwig, Co-Founder of the Whole 30

We know that a lot of people love the Costco store because they do not fall short on offering certain healthy staples.  That being said, Costco is undoubtedly inexpensive because the taste quality is simply not the same. The same can be said for a lot of other places you can get meat as well.

Costco is not necessarily 100%  grass-fed, grass-finished, whereas Butcher Box is. And if it isn’t 100% grass-finished, then it's loaded with unhealthy fat from corn and soy at the end of production - a practice which limits the better health benefits you would otherwise get from pasture-raised, free-range produce.

Butcher Box Menu Options & Plans

The first box we tried had quite limited meat options. Over time, we must admit we still got bored eventually, with frequently ordering top sirloin steaks, ground beef, quality roasts, and a little heritage breed bacon on the side.

But over the years, there have been signs of improvement. Now, you can choose from multiple cuts of meat, which can help you craft different organic food recipes, depending on your needs. Did we mention there are super tender steaks?

Here are a few examples of their menu options:

  • New York strip steaks
  • Pork tenderloin
  • Chicken tenders
  • Chicken breasts
  • Top sirloin steaks
  • Ribeyes
  • Chuck roast
  • Heritage pork chops and bacon
  • Sausages
  • Ribs
  • Salmon
  • Boneless pork

The main thing a real carnivore might still be missing is organ meat. But other than that, there’s a fairly good selection of products to cover every meal. For organ meat, we recommend you check out US Wellness Meats.

List of Types of Meat You Can Have Delivered

  • Mixed box - This can be a random mix of grass-fed chicken and pork. A mix of various marine produce can also be included.
  • All-beef option box - This box contains a varied selection from ground beef to filet mignons.
  • Beef and pork box - Provides about a 50/50 split in weight between pork and beef.
  • Beef and chicken box - Provides about a 50/50 split in weight between beef and chicken.
  • Custom box - Allows you to handpick your meat cuts and a couple of add-ons, too. Neat, isn’t it?

We have to note that the first 4 ButcherBox options are pre-selected, meaning you can’t pick the grass-fed meats you get. The Custom Box is the only option where you can make a selection to your liking and roundup the cost. At Carnivore Style, each month we would get a customized packaging because we like to prepare a different steak recipe or two - although this also tends to be the most expensive package option, depending on your choice.

You can also select the box size that you want the meat delivered, which mainly comes in two sizes:

  1. 8 to 11 lbs box - Suitable for couples and sharing among small families.
  2. 16 to 22 lbs box - Suitable for families with 4-5 members or if you have a freezer with enough storage room.

For larger families or people who rely on the whole chicken, boneless pork, steak, and beef combo deals as their only source of protein throughout the week, ordering the 8 to 11 lbs box may not be the best of solutions. Instead, the Big ButcherBox option might actually come at a less expensive price!

How Goes The Ordering Process?

Butcher Box un frozen meat

You can get your hands on good quality meat in a fairly simple three-step ordering process:

  1. You build your box - You have the option to pick and buy one of their pre-curated shipment boxes, or customize your own when you add grass-fed beef, free-range chicken, and pork – you have total control.
  2. Get Your Delivery - Your meat cuts reaches your door frozen, carefully packed in an insulated box, and free of charge.
  3. Defrost, cook, and dig in - No need to really explain things here.

You can order your box from the store either every 30 days or 1 month or 60 days. The 2-month option is way good if you want to stock up and save costs over time, or if you just want to avoid overeating.

How Much Does ButcherBox Cost?

denver steak

Of course, monthly pricing depends on the type of meat box you choose. We like eating organic ground beef the most, but you can either select a classic box for just a price of over $100.

This usually includes 8-11 pounds that can be used for roughly 24 meal preparations. Or a classic big box that you'll have to pay for around twice as much, which contains 16 to 22 pounds that is equivalent to 48 meals.

On the other hand, in a custom box, you can specify and put which cuts of meat you want to buy and share. The small custom option costs about $150 with 9 to 14 pounds of meat.

A big custom box is close to $270, which has 18 to 26 pounds of organic meat cuts. Whatever you order, and whether you like it small or big, just keep in mind to leave a good bit of freezer space to store all that new food. Having to toss all that delicious ButcherBox beef and steak would really be a nightmare.

Here Is A Breakdown Of The Price

  1. Custom Box - 9-14 lbs for $4.97 average per meal
  2. The Mixed Box - 8.5 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average per meal
  3. The Beef & Pork Box - 8 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average per meal
  4. The Beef & Chicken Box - 8.5 - 11 lbs for $5.38 average per meal
  5. The All-Beef Box - 8 - 10 lbs for $5.38 average per meal

How Does Butcher Box Arrive?

To ensure nothing gets spoiled during transport, the Butcher Box meat packaging is transported to your front door frozen and vacuumed packed in a black freezer bag filled with dry ice.

The ideal way to really defrost meat is by leaving it in the fridge overnight. If you are in a hurry, the next best thing is to place the frozen meat in a plastic bag or wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and give it a cold water bath.

For instance, defrosting a salmon will take roughly an hour, depending on its size and thickness. We'd recommend checking the water in 30 minutes and changing it if it starts to become tepid. After the meat is defrosted, don't think about waiting anymore. It's best to cook it straight away and start eating.

Goes without saying, under no circumstances should you refreeze the raw meat for another day. Also, make sure to have enough space going on in your refrigerator, so you don't need to cook a lot of your Butcher Box straight away. These tips will come in handy.

Delivery Frequency

Butcher Box patty meat

Lastly, you can also set the frequency of your ButcherBox meat box delivery. This includes how many times a month, you want to order. We would also have to note, if you’re on a strict carnivore diet, you'll need to order a big packaging for any meat recipe.

On the downside, while there are many kinds of options to choose from, you won’t really find organ meat. Moreover, if you like having some occasional fish from time to time, you'll usually find your eating options somewhat limited. If you’re looking for more crustacean options, see Crowd Cow as an alternative.

3 Reasons Why Butcher Box Might Be Worth It

Yes, Butcher Box is worth it. The taste of high-quality organic meat is really worth spending a certain portion of your food budget. Having made a few orders ourselves and reading through countless customer reviews, we’ve boiled down all benefits to these following 3 reasons.

1. Value For Money

Given the high-quality prime meat, we'd say you will be getting more bang for your buck. By subscribing, you can regularly treat yourself to reasonably priced meats like grass-fed ground beef and organic chicken. After all, life is too short to eat bad steaks.

And if you buy in bulk, you can get even better value for the price. If by any chance, you received damaged goods, you can also ask for a refund.

2. Convenience

Besides having ways to lower the costs, having your food transported to your door beats visiting a local grocery store anytime. Our first big order came without issues - and we got to enjoy free bacon to share and feed everyone. Great, indeed.

3. Customer Service

We've only had to deal with a customer service representative twice. The first time we really needed to delay the shipping one day as we were unexpectedly away from home. The second time was due to a minor issue on the delivered amount that was immediately rectified.

In both situations, we were impressed with their customer service. We like how they deal with their clients.

Happy Customer Reviews

Butcher Box happy customers


happy customers from Butcher Box

real customer testimonial and review


testimonials from two people


How long can a Butcher Box stay outside on the front porch?

According to the company, your Butcher Box order can stay on the front porch for about 6 to 8 hours. It’s packaged using dry ice to maintain constant temperature, but you might also want to account for a different time of the year as well as direct exposure to sunlight.

Is Butcher Box less expensive than grocery stores?

No, Butcher Box is really more expensive than grocery stores. However, given the quality of products and the convenience of having fresh organic meats transported to your doorstep, the price tends to be worth it. Subscribing spares you from having to regularly visit a grocery store. You'll get the best value for your money.

Does ButcherBox have fish?

Yes, ButcherBox has fish available to order as add-ons. At present, the seafood shopping choice is limited to wild-caught salmon and scallops, but that might be enough to get a bit of variety into your daily food planning.

Can you skip months with the ButcherBox subscription service?

Yes, you can with the ButcherBox subscription. You can choose an option where you are allowed to pause the service every other month or for up to 6 months without any extra cost or fees.

Is ButcherBox cheaper than Costco?

No, ButcherBox isn’t cheaper compared to Costco. However, the fact that their products are freshly delivered to your doorstep must be taken into account. Also, the products are made from organic, grass-fed animals. So given the top-notch meat quality and intricate product preparation, it comes as no surprise that they will cost you more money than Costco.

Is ButcherBox cheaper than Whole Foods?

No, Butcher Box isn’t cheaper than Whole Foods. The high-quality meat comes from grass-fed and grass-finished animals. The food is not mass-produced and takes a longer time to cultivate. Hence, they may be more expensive to produce.

How often does Butcher Box deliver?

Butcher Box delivers orders according to your requested frequency, which can be every week, every month or every other month.

Does ButcherBox accept EBT?

No, ButcherBox is unable to accept EBT cards at this time due to COVID-19 regulations and they do not accept PayPal as well. However, this problem could change at a later date.

How long does it take to ship my ButcherBox order?

It takes about 3 to 6 business days for ButcherBox to ship products to your doorstep, after they charge your credit card. This mainly depends on two things:

  1. Your volume of orders
  2. Your location

Final Thoughts on ButcherBox

After this thoughtful review, we believe ButcherBox is definitely worth trying out.

Even if it doesn’t serve as your primary source of main cooking ingredients, one of the main highlights is the good selection of grass-fed quality meat. Organic food always has a better taste, so it's a no-brainer there.

But in our opinion, the best benefit of all is the affordability of their subscription package. Not only do you get to curate your product box with all manner of savory items, but it will also be shipped to your front door, free of charge.

And considering that we don't need to visit the grocery store during a Coronavirus pandemic whenever we feel like getting fed grass-finished beef - we'd say that's one huge plus.

So give them a try, see if they're great or not. Let us know how that decision on Butcher Box worked out for you.

Butcher box package


#1 Meat Delivery Service

  • Grass-fed beef delivered directly to your door
  • Without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
Click For Best Price
payment icons

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *