ButcherBox Review
Is It a Good Deal? Plans, Pricing and More

Butcher Box Reviews Featured Image

Getting all the cuts of meat you need at a reasonable price is challenging. Luckily, there are meat delivery services that can address this issue. In this review, let me show you everything you need to know about ButcherBox and how it can bring you high quality meats right at your doorstep.

In the past, I’ve had some experiences with meat delivery services for keto and paleo diets. So when I shifted to a carnivore dietary plan, I'm hoping to see if I could also get everything on my meat shopping list conveniently shipped to me as well.

Turns out, ButcherBox can make it possible. Their meat delivery service offers an array of meat box options at a reasonable price. Plus, their shipping is quite fast, too.

What Is ButcherBox?

ButcherBox is a meat delivery service offering subscription packages that contain varying amounts and types of meat. The company said that they would like to give their customers an affordable access to high quality meats that are humanely raised by local farmers in well-kept farms. ButcherBox offers 100% grass fed, grass finished beef, and chicken that are free from hormones and additives. Their pork is from heritage breeds who never fed with non-organic feeds. Given these, you would never need to worry about eating ButcherBox meats.

ButcherBox offers quality standards that you would be able to find at a Whole Foods store, but usually at a premium price. Like with most bulk purchases, you can save money by ordering in bulk and setting up a regular subscription plan with ButcherBox

This brings me to the next question...

How Does ButcherBox Work?

bbq pork on a table

ButcherBox works through meat box subscriptions. First, to be a member, sign up for a profile in their website. Next, after setting up your account, start looking for the meat sets that's suitable to your dietary regimen. Pick the products you will buy and choose the frequency of the shipment and your preferred dates, then you're all set.

Here are the different subscriptions plans you should know. Check them out below. 

Available ButcherBox Plans

Choose below the type of sets you want to buy. You can find additional details in the official website, too.

  • Mixed Box: This can be a random mix of different cuts like grass fed beef, pork, and chicken. There are  various portions of fish as well, like salmon. 
  • All Beef Box: If you love eating beef, then this classic box might be a better choice for you. You can select from different beef options like grass fed ground beef, porterhouse steak, sirloin steaks, and filet mignons.
  • Beef and pork box: Provides about a 50/50 split in weight between the pork, beef choices.
  • Beef and chicken box: Provides about a 50/50 split in weight between the two types of meat.
  • Custom Box: If you prefer to get all your favorite meats at once, then this box might be a better option for you. This allows you to handpick choices you can include like chicken breasts or grass fed ground beef.

Size

Pick the box size that you prefer, corresponding to the amount of items you will go for.

  1. 1
    8 to 11 lbs box: This is great for individuals and good for sharing among three to five people
  2. 2
    16 to 22 lbs box: This might be better for families and gatherings, or if you have a large freezer

Choose Some Add Ons

Next, check out the add ons. You can try to add something extra special every month like salmon, scallops, halibut, and organic chicken, too.

Delivery Frequency

Lastly, choose the frequency of your meat box delivery. How many times every month do you want to order? If you’re on a strict carnivore regimen and you're only eating meat, then it can be better if you order a big box every week or two.

ButcherBox Pros And Cons

person slicing meat

In this section of my ButcherBox review post, I am going to highlight the main benefits that I love, along with a couple of negatives.

First of all, I love that quality of the ButcherBox meats does live up to the their claims. Their ribeye steak has great fat marbling and is really one of the best steaks I have ever tasted. Thanks to ButcherBox, I'm never going to worry about the quality of my food. Their meats are tender and very easy to cook, which I love as well. And since each product arrives fresh at my doorstep, each bite has a rich umami taste, and smells very aromatic and delicious.

The organic chicken is tasty, and you can tell the difference in the grass fed beef (yes, I did do a taste test with some “industrial” beef).

On the other hand, in my experience, the speed of ButcherBox's delivery service is something I really appreciate. I love how it helps me save time and effort, since I don't need to go to the grocery store anymore. And with the outstanding quality and taste of the meat cuts I get, ordering from ButcherBox is better than visiting my local grocery stores or butcher. I can also add fish like salmon, scallops, and halibut. Thanks to ButcherBox, I can have less worries about the quality of the food I am cooking.

Benefits

  • Grass fed beef
  • Humanely raised Heritage breed pork [1]
  • Free-range chicken
  • Flexible sizes and delivery frequency
  • Good pricing when buying in bulk

Downsides

  • True carnivore dieters would still need to source organ meat
  • Some people would like to see more fish options

On the downside, during my review, I found out that you won’t find organ meat in their sets. If you like having something more special occasionally like salmon or tuna, you might find your options limited.

What Do You Get?

In each package, you can either pick a random selection or a specific ready-made box. 

In my experience last June 2018, the first order I tried from ButcherBox still has limited options.

This meant I would easily get bored with frequently ordering options like strip steak, top sirloin steak, and and roasts.

But over the years, there have been quite a few changes. During this review, I see that we can already fill a box with multiple grass fed meat portions. This can totally help you craft a unique food recipe for you and your family every meal. Right now, I particularly like the mixed box and the custom box. 

Here are a few examples of the popular cuts of meat you can enjoy:

box
  • New York strip steak
  • Pork tenderloin
  • Chicken tenders
  • Chicken breasts
  • Top sirloin steak
  • Ribeye steak
  • Steak tips
  • Beef tips
  • Chuck roast
  • Heritage pork steak 
  • Bacon
  • Sausages
  • Ribs
  • Salmon
  • Boneless pork

As I said above, the main thing a real carnivore might miss is the organ meat. But other than that, you can find a great selection of meat to cover all meals.

How Much Does ButcherBox Cost Per Month?

The cost of a ButcherBox per month will depend on the type of meat box you choose. You can either select from classic curated boxes or custom boxes. In a classic box, ButcherBox will be the one to pick the items for you. A small curated box can cost you $129. This includes 8-11 pounds that can be used for 24 meal preparations that may be good for sharing for two to four persons for two weeks. A big curated box is $238, which contains 16 to 22 pounds that's equivalent to 48 meals good for sharing with your family and friends for a couple of weeks.

On the other hand, in a custom box, you can specify which portions you want to buy. Choose between their free range chicken, beef, or pork options. A small custom box is $149 with 9 to 14 pounds of meat. A big custom box is $270, which has 18 to 26 pounds of meat. Whether you go for the classic or curated box, just keep in mind to leave a good bit of freezer space to store it all.

One great way to budget money is to buy a big box with your friends and family. As an example, you can budget a pound or two of pork is enough for two to three persons per meal. Through this, you can save much more money and even split on the shipment cost. 

Here is the Pricing Breakdown:

  • Custom Box: 9-14 lbs equivalent to an average of $4.97 per meal
  • The Mixed Box: 8.5 - 11 lbs equivalent to around $5.38 per meal
  • The Beef & Pork Box: 8 - 11 lbs equivalent to around $5.38 per meal
  • The Beef & Chicken Box: 8.5 - 11 lbs equivalent to about $5.38 average per meal
  • The All Beef Box: 8 - 10 lbs equivalent to about $5.38  per meal

The Quality Of the Meat

To give an honest review, I can really say that each ButcherBox product is made with the top quality. I feel comfortable getting my protein fix from them, since I know that each cut is free from additives and are ethically-produced. In my experience, I can absolutely taste the difference when I tried eating a ButcherBox steak, as compared to the ones I got from the local butcher or grocery store. And in my opinion, free-range chicken and eggs taste so much better, too.

The company only uses certified sources of best quality grass fed and grass finished beef, free range chicken, and heritage pork. This means that each cut you'll be eating have never been injected with herbicides, antibiotics [2], and hormones [3]. 

Professional bloggers and foodies who also post a review after they tried a ButcherBox product agree that their top-notch quality meat choices are some of the best they have ever had. They don't have any complaints with the quality of food they received. As an example, check out this review post below by Melissa Hartwig:

It is important to me and my community that our animal protein sources are naturally and responsibly raised and grass fed. For this reason, I trust and recommend ButcherBox.
- Melissa Hartwig, Co-Founder of the Whole 30

Is ButcherBox Worth It?

Person slicing salmon meat

Yes, in my opinion, I think ButcherBox is worth it. During my review, I tried a variety of options and confirmed that each of their high quality meat cut is worth spending for. Not only are they healthier, they have a richer taste as well. Having used the service on a regular basis and read through other people's review, I’ve brought down all benefits to these following 3 reasons.

1 - Value For Money

Given the high quality prime meat that you can get from ButcherBox, you can totally get the bang for the buck. Ordering from ButcherBox is as close as you can get to ordering directly from farms and ranches. With their meat sets, you can regularly treat yourself to a reasonably priced but top-notch quality meat like grass fed ground beef. One good way to save money is to buy a big box with your family and friends, so you can share the cost with them.

I  still like going to my local butcher sometimes to look for any great deals, but I think the quality I've been getting from ButcherBox can't be beaten.

2 - Convenience

Having high quality food shipped directly to your door makes always life so much easier than regularly visiting a local grocery store. I get to save so much time. The first big order I got was sent to me without any hassle. It was very frozen when I came home. That's when I knew how big of a convenience this service would be. And, eating healthy won't be too much of a problem for me anymore. 

During my first box, I found out that I can choose from a wide array of choices- from chicken tenders to boneless pork. For a limited time, new members can even enjoy free bacon as well.

Unless you have a really strict dietary needs, it's nice to avail of the mixed box as a way to get a regular surprise of many different cuts in a box. And to make it easier for you to cook, ButcherBox also has a lot of easy recipes posted online. 

3 - Customer Service

I thank ButcherBox's customer service representatives a lot because they're very easy to talk to. You can generally reach to them through the company's website. I've only had to deal with a customer service representative twice, for the first box I got. Once, because I really needed to delay the shipment of my package as I was unexpectedly away from home. The next time was due to a minor issue on the shipped amount that was immediately rectified. In both situations, I was impressed with their representatives as they patiently told me everything I need to know. 

During my review, I learned that it's very reassuring to be able to reach a service representative fast. So if you like to report any issues about your package to their customer service or even file for refund, you can just shoot an email to the company. Another option is to fill out their website's Contact Us form with your first name, email address, and message.

Who Should Consider Trying Out ButcherBox?

roast chicken on roasting pan in oven

To summarize my review post, I think everyone should make ButcherBox a part of their lifestyle, most especially the carnivore dieters and busy families. Everyone could save time from having their food delivered, and at the same time, enjoy the organic and ethically-sourced meat that ButcherBox has to offer.

Carnivore Dieters

As already mentioned, it's really very convenient for carnivore dieters to have a reliable source of great meat. Eating healthy will not be much of a problem for them anymore. ButcherBox sells a lot of organic and grass fed products at an affordable price. They will ship your package pretty fast, too. 

Busy Families

Grocery store shopping is really a struggle for busy families. If you would like to save some money and time, then it's wise to subscribe from ButcherBox every month. They can always cover all your family's protein needs. Your family can buy in bulk and just store them in the freezer for the week. By ordering from ButcherBox, you would be able to have less frequent visits at the groceries or your local butcher, and just focus on your other important activities.

Anyone Planning A BBQ Party

If you are planning a party or choose to serve BBQ for a lot of people, then you could be able to get all you need with the custom box packages. To help you prepare for a party, ButcherBox also has quick and easy recipes posted on their page. You can follow these recipes and make organic ground beef hamburger patties or even grilled pork chops that you could get from their meat boxes. Share these yummy dishes with your friends and family, and they will surely love it.

Where Do You Order?

smiling man using tablet

You can try ordering a box via the company's website or join their waitlist if there's any.

Alternatively, you could call or email directly to ButcherBox to place your order. Another review post that I saw suggested that it's a better way to get dibs on their stocks, since their waitlist gets long sometimes.

One good tip I would want you to know is that it's helpful to plan and review the meals and recipe ideas in advance either weekly or monthly. Planning your ingredients will help you avoid buying unnecessary ingredients, therefore making you spend less. This will help you organize all your dietary needs, too. Do you usually cook meals with ground beef or chicken breasts? Then add many of these cuts in your shopping list. 

And over the coming months, it's a good experiment to start spicing up your beef recipe to start adding more seafood, chicken, and pork.

Positive Reviews

Butcher Box Happy customer reviews
Satisfied Customer reviews
Positive consumer reviews
real feedback from satisfied clients

FAQs

How long can it stay outside on the front porch?

How is the ButcherBox meat shipped?

Where does ButcherBox deliver to?

Is ButcherBox cheaper than grocery stores?

Does ButcherBox have fish?

How long does it take to ship my order?

Can you skip months with the subscription service?

Is ButcherBox cheaper than Costco?

Where do the meats come from?

Is ButcherBox cheaper than Whole Foods?

Are the meats delivered frozen?

How often does ButcherBox deliver?

Does ButcherBox offer refunds?

Does ButcherBox have a referral program?

Is ButcherBox Worth Trying Out?

Yes, I think ButcherBox is worth trying out, given my honest review.

I would also encourage you to read another ButcherBox post on the official site, to know more insights. 

And as for me, the main highlight of this subscription facility is the good selection of 100% grass fed meats, which I can resort to when I go through my carnivore cycle.

Try out one of the ButcherBox boxes now. Let us know in social media how it worked out for you.

#1 Meat Delivery Service

ButcherBox

  • High quality meat delivered right to your door
  • Humanely raised without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
  • Get the BEST PRICE until the end of March

Timothy Woods
Follow me

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *