If you've ever attempted to order steaks online, you know that one of the major concerns is consistency. Our team researched all the self-proclaimed "premium quality" meat providers, and the truth is, finding the right seller is a difficult feat when you value freshness, taste, and marbling, as we do.

After reading some online reviews, we found one company that strictly offers USDA Prime beef. In this Chicago Steak Company review and taste test, we'll find out how their reputation holds up and if their "juicy" steaks are worth the cost.

What Is The Chicago Steak Company?

The Chicago Steak Company is a “steaks for delivery” outfit with its roots in the Union Stock Yards of Chicago. They source their beef from the finest Heritage Cattle in the Mid-West and have won multiple awards for the quality of their meats. (1)

Chicago Steak Company caters both to high-end steakhouses and 5-star hotel chains, as well as the regular consumer market, which in turn, prepares some of our favorites - from flavorful USDA prime burgers to the delicious sirloin and flat iron steak. They specialize in wet and dry-aged steaks and claim to have the largest dry-aging facility in the Mid-West.

Pros
  • Steaks aged four to six weeks
  • Great Steak Debate Peoples Choice Award winner
  • Same meats, steak, and fish as high-end restaurants
  • Both wet and dry-aged cut options
Cons
  • No grass-fed farm-raised options
  • No subscription box options

What Are The Menu Options?

Chicago Steaks on a table

Though the Chicago Steak Company specializes in high-end steak and prime cut, you can also send an order for a variety of meats, seafood, and other food options to make tasty burgers or country breakfast meals. They have an available selection of desserts and amazing gift basket choices you can order and share with family and friends. Some of their most highly rated categories you can choose from their site include:

Premium Angus Beef

  • Filet Mignon
  • Boneless Strip Steaks
  • Tomahawk Ribeye

Wet Aged

  • Bone-In Ribeye
  • T-Bone Steaks
  • Filet Mignon Steaks

Dry-Aged

  • Boneless Ribeye
  • Filet Mignon Steaks
  • Tomahawk Ribeye

American Wagyu Beef

  • Ribeye
  • Filet Mignon
  • Porterhouse Steaks

Steak Burgers

  • USDA Prime Burgers
  • Gourmet Angus Steak Burgers
  • American Wagyu Burgers

Chicken/Pork/Ribs

  • Whole Chicken
  • Baby Back Ribs by Coach Ditka
  • Pork Chops

For more gift basket options, check Harry and David and Goldbelly for gourmet food and gifts.

Chicago Steak Company Meat Quality

tomahawk premium angus

The quality of meat cut we received from the Chicago Steak Company shop was top-notch. The steak flavor complexity was way robust, and the Wagyu we ordered, buttery and tender - perfect in every bite.

Because the company only offers prime beef cuts and not USDA Choice like many companies, each steak cut you receive will be high-quality.

While many companies try and pass off USDA Choice as a premium product, this company seems to be the real deal. They never cease to amaze loyal customers when it comes to consistently delivering some of the best steaks, USDA prime burgers, and meal packages at your front door. The reviews we read confirm that.

For more meat options with the same quality and value, check our Top 5 Places to Buy Prime Steaks.

How Does The Price Compare?

The prices of their beef, steaks, and other meats vary greatly depending on the specific hand cut and the quantity of the meat you select and order. Still, based on our research, they are comparable to similar steak and beef providers offering the same caliber.

At the lower end are their chicken and pork cuts, and on the higher end are their USDA Prime and American Wagyu beef cuts. Since this is all delivered meat, there are extra considerations, such as shipping costs, which we will get to later.

Some examples of pricing based on their best selling items include:

  • USDA Prime Angus Beef Burger - 80z for around $100 (on sale)
  • USDA Prime Steak Dry Aged Ribeye - 4 x 12oz Steaks for roughly $180 (on sale)
  • USDA Prime Wet Aged Boneless Strip Steak - 4 x 10oz Steaks for about $150 (on sale)

Chicago Steak Shipping Fees

The only genuine downside of the Chicago Steak Company is that they charge fees for every package shipped, although they're known to often offer free shipping promo codes, so watch out for those. While they charge fees for one-off purchases, shipping is free with subscriptions.

With such high-end meat delivery services, though, paying the shipping fees shouldn't be much of a problem. If you want to get up to date with shipping information, including discounts and shopping coupons, we recommend you visit their official website.

Chicago Steak Company Delivery Areas

chicago steak for dinner

Chicago Steak Company delivers steak, beef, burgers, and other meats throughout the United States. The upside is that they deliver to all fifty states, whereas many online companies would only deliver to the mainland. This means people in Hawaii and Alaska can enjoy premium Angus beef and American Wagyu beef products.

How Does Your Order Arrive?

When we ordered the Wagyu filet mignon, prime rib, sirloin, and a dry-aged bone-in ribeye, it arrived days after at our doorstep, frozen right and in good shape. All of the products were individually wrapped. The packaging was vacuum-sealed before being flash frozen.

The steak cuts were packed inside boxes and then placed in a cooler packed with dry ice. Make sure to check the time on the delivery day so you'll be home to ensure your meats stay fresh.

Customer Support & Ratings

The company has high marks for service on various review platforms. While reading several Chicago Steak Company reviews, one thing that stood out to us was their open, helpful, and consistent communication with customers on Trust Pilot and Facebook.

This is always a good sign that they are receptive to customer feedback. This, plus their satisfaction guarantee, gives them an easy leg up over similar meat delivery providers.

“The quality of their product and top-rate customer service keeps me coming back to Chicago Steaks as a trusted source to purchase gifts and supplies.”

-Rick, Trust Pilot Verified Reviewer

Company Reviews

New York strip steak on cutting board

After testing multiple products and researching other Chicago Steak Company reviews, we find them to have some of the best beef, burgers, and prime steak cut on the market. We love how the company is similar to Omaha Steaks but has better pricing when you make an order. They do have a lot more to offer for us hardcore meat and steak lovers.

Chicago Steaks Company provides a good option for delivered steaks. Here is some additional information we gathered online:

  1. Better Business Bureau (BBB) Rating: Chicago Steak has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau. They have 0 complaints from customers on the website (2).
  2. Trust Pilot: The company has over 848 ratings on Trust Pilot. The average review is four stars, with 72% of reviewers giving them an excellent rating and 10% a great score (3).
  3. Facebook Page: Over 30 thousand people like the Chicago Steak Facebook page. They have a rating of 4.3 out of 5 based on the opinion of 251 people.

Chicago Steak Company - Our Verdict?

After reading other Chicago Steak Company reviews and ordering a few meaty delights ourselves, we think that while this meat delivery provider does deliver quality products,  it lacks the high-quality flavor and tenderness that our palates were craving for. When it comes to exquisite steak and meat, ButcherBox is our consistent go-to place.

We've always been impressed with their organic grass-fed beef selection and excellent pricing when we're buying in bulk. Apart from superior quality, what sets ButcherBox apart from other steak providers is that you can curate your own box and have it delivered right to your doorstep, free of charge.

Butcher box package

Recommended Meat Service

ButcherBox

  • Grass-fed beef delivered directly to your door
  • Without antibiotics or added hormones
  • Customizable boxes available
  • Select from up to 21 different cuts
Click For Best Price
payment icons

About the author