Moink Box and Butcher Box are two meat delivery services that bear a lot of similarities. To determine which is superior, we opted to place orders from both and evaluate their offerings.
Following a taste test, we identified a distinct victor in the Moink vs Butcher Box comparison. Below are the key points from our experience and all the essential details you should be aware of before making a purchase.
Moink Box & Butcher Box Primary Differences
Butcher Box beats Moink Box in variety, offering over 60 meat options compared to Moink's 30, and delivers nationwide. Moink, on the other hand, misses Alaska and Hawaii. Both champion humane farming from family farms, but Butcher Box takes the lead with a broader mix of heritage pork, ground beef, and organic chicken.
Customer service-wise, Butcher Box wins again, mixing user-friendly support with email and phone options. Moink sticks to just phone and email.
ButcherBox
- Ships to all 50 states
- Over 60 meat options with 5 box offerings
- Consumer service includes website help topics, phone support, and email support
- Sells premium quality grass-fed and grass-finished beef, heritage pork chops, free-range organic chicken, and wild-caught seafood
Moink Box
- Ships to 48 states
- Around 30 meat options with 4 box offerings
- Support service includes phone and email support
- Sells high-quality grass-fed beef, lamb, pork, and wild-caught seafood
How Does the Quality Compare?
The quality of both companies is similar when it comes to where they source their meat. Unlike many of the other meat delivery service providers, both companies focus on grass-fed and grass-finished and grass-fed beef, clean chicken, and pork. For another kind of pork, however, you might want to have Kurobuta instead.
Both companies claim that their meat comes from animals that are free of growth hormones and GMO grains. The meat at both companies is well above the quality you get at grocery stores. One perk of both companies is they have a satisfaction guarantee, so if you're not happy with the meat quality, there are options.
Comparing Sourcing Practices
ButcherBox sources all of their meats from family farms throughout the USA. The company has strict standards for the raising of the animals they source. Some of these standards include:
- No hormones or antibiotics
- All animals must be able to roam free
- Humanely raised using sustainable practices
Moink partners with over a hundred local farms and two on Tunisia, near Australia. Both Moink and Butcher Box, which has a slight edge, focus on small, ethical, and humane farming. Heeding advice from the Humane Farm Animal Care Program, they oversee everything from farm to fork, ensuring top-notch, ethically raised meats.
Check these other meat comparison guides:
- Omaha Steaks vs Kansas City Steaks
- Chicago Steaks vs Omaha Steaks
- Omaha Steaks vs ButcherBox
- US Wellness Meats vs ButcherBox
Butcher Box & Moink Box Menu Options
Butcher Box has more meat options. They are a larger company and work with a larger number of farms so that they can source more ground beef, pork, free-range organic chicken, and seafood cuts than some other companies. While they don't offer as many options as companies like Crowd Cow, what they do offer is generally of a higher quality.
| MOINK | BUTCHERBOX |
|---|---|
| Offers grass-fed beef, chicken, pork and some seafood options. | Offers chicken, grass-fed beef, pork, and seafood. |
| Beef selections include ground beef, boneless ribeye, stew meat, chuck roast, rump roast, New York strip steaks, and flank steak. | The company offers only grass fed beef. Some of their options include New York strip steak, steak tips, sirloin steaks, porterhouse steak, and more. |
| For pork, they offer breakfast sausage, bacon, ground pork, boneless pork chop, and shoulder roast. | All of the pork the company sells is heritage breed pork. These are particular pig breeds that are known for being fattier and healthier due to their clear raising. |
| Their organic chicken selection includes chicken drumsticks, bone-in split chicken breasts, chicken wings, chicken tenders, and boneless skinless chicken breast. They also offer wild-caught salmon. | Cuts the company offers include whole pork tenderloin, boneless pork chops, thick cut bacon, and more. You can also get chicken and salmon cuts from the company. |
Moink vs Butcher Box: Price
Both firms provide monthly meat subscription boxes. Moink offers four varied price tiers tailored to your meat preferences. It has two packages: a pre-selected monthly option and one you can fully personalize.
Moink's four packages include two small choices (with or without pork) costing $129 for 6.5 lbs of meat, and two medium options (also with or without pork) priced at $159 for roughly 12 lbs of grass-fed meat.
The options for purchasing meat from ButcherBox are their curated classic for $124 with 8-11lbs of grass-fed meat, the curated big package for $238 with 16-22 lbs of meat, the classic custom box for $149 with 9-14 lbs of meat, and the custom big package for $270 with 18-26 lbs of meat.
Shipping and Delivery Area
Butcher Box has a slightly larger delivery area than its competitor, though both ship monthly. Now, let's dive into the specifics of each company's delivery zones.
Moink Box
Moink ships meat boxes nationwide via FedEx, dispatching orders every Tuesday. Expect your package by Thursday, or Wednesday if you're lucky. Once shipped, check your email for a tracking number to keep tabs on your box. Run into delivery snags? Reach out to Moink Box's responsive customer support. They're quick to offer a full refund or replace items in your next box.
Tip: Report any issues within a week of delivery to make the most of Moink's perks.
ButcherBox
ButcherBox delivers meat across the U.S., barring Alaska and Hawaii, and is brainstorming ways to include these states and Canada.
Meat boxes ship from the facility weekdays, with deliveries landing from Tuesday to Saturday.
You can opt to receive packages at home or the office, though ButcherBox advises against it to avoid missed deliveries during restricted business hours.
How About the Packaging?
The packaging from Butcher Box is individually frozen and vacuum-packed for delivery. It is is eco-friendly and features inbuilt insulation so that your meat stays fresh while in the hands of the delivery service.
Moink Box ships all of their meat in a similar way with the main difference being their packaging isn't specified as eco-friendly or recycled.
Moink vs Butcher Box: Service Terms
Moink Box and Butcher Box have similar services, but how do they hold up against each other? Discovering this aspect of their company ensures you know what to get for your needs.
Moink Box
The company launched its meat subscription service prioritizing cost-effectiveness and variety. As a newbie, you've got four unique membership plans to choose from, each offering a mix of meat and seafood. You decide how often you want your meat box delivered and what's in it. Moink keeps it fresh with a rotating selection, so you're in for a treat every time. Feel free to mix and match from their current offerings, like going all-in on grass-fed beef or throwing in some wild-caught salmon, chicken, or occasional lamb.
Also while the company handpicks your meats, you've got the freedom to swap items as you please, making their unlimited substitutions the cherry on top.
As for delivery frequency, here are the possible alternatives:
- Once every three weeks
- Once every month
- Once every six weeks
All memberships through Moink Box are flexible, allowing you to reschedule shipping or put more products on your package. The best part is you can opt for a different subscription type or cancel it whenever you desire.
Butcher Box
This membership-based meat shipping service gives you fresh and high-quality meats at your doorstep. Your options include a monthly subscription or receiving a package every other month, based on your needs.
You can also pick from either convenience alternatives or premium cuts. The company has two types of boxes:
- Curated Box. The Butcher Box team curates the cuts included in this package.
- Custom Box. This option allows you to select your desired cuts and let Butcher Box deliver them to your doorstep.
Pick your box size and contents. The perk? Tons of benefits with every plan. Butcher Box offers unique deals for members, including free shipping, recipe ideas, and more perks. Like Moink, Butcher Box lets you pause or cancel subscriptions whenever you want
Butcher Box vs Moink Box: Winner
When it comes to Moink vs Butcher Box, we find Butcher Box to be the high-quality option. We like their heritage pork, and the NY strip was especially tasty. Depending on your order, they may also offer free bacon or other add-ons, which is a big plus.
Because the company has a broader delivery area and free shipping, it's simple for meat lovers anywhere in the country to order. Their delivery frequency also makes it easy to stay stocked throughout the month.
What's next? Take a look at our blog post featuring the best meat pie delivery service.
#1 Meat Delivery Service
ButcherBox
- Grass-fed and grass-finished beef delivered directly to your door
- Without antibiotics or added hormones
- Customizable boxes available
- Select from up to 21 different cuts
- Get the BEST PRICE until the end of July
- No organ meat
