Every carnivore I know loves a good steak, and two of the most popular types are the New York strip and the ribeye steaks. But what makes these cuts of meat different from each other, and which should you choose?
Well, I have researched the New York strip vs ribeye topic thoroughly, both with my favorite butcher and also on my grill. Read on to see what I have learned.
Summary of the Key Findings
- The New York strip is a flavorful steak that is great on the grill
- The ribeye steak is a well-marbled cut that is tender and juicy
- Both cuts have their place on the menu - but personal preference will dictate which one you choose
5 Characteristics of NY Strip
To start the comparison of these two steaks, let's look at the New York strip steak.
The New York strip is a cut of beef that comes from the short loin area of the cow. The short loin is the area right in front of the rear leg, behind the ribs.
The steak is cut from the cow's longissimus dorsi, an underused muscle group. This makes New York strip steak quite tender.
Interestingly, the New York strip makes up half of a Porterhouse steak, and a thick band of fat usually lies along one side of the steak .
2. Shape and Size
The New York strip steak is long and thin, with a rectangular shape. It typically weighs between 8 and 12 ounces. It is not a particularly fatty cut of beef, so the New York strip usually comes about 1 to 1 1/2 inches thick in order to keep it from drying out during cooking.
The New York strip steak goes by quite a few different aliases. These include:
- Omaha strip
- Shell steak
- Veiny steak
- Top Loin steak
- Strip Loin steak
- Ambassador steak
- Boneless Club steak
- Hotel-Style/Cut steak
- Country Club steak
- Kansas City steak/strip
4. Taste and Texture
The New York strip steak is known for its rich, beefy flavor. This is due to the low amount of marbling in the meat, which gives it a lot of flavor.
Despite the lower fat content, the steak has a smooth texture and is also quite tender, making it a popular choice for those who want a leaner steak.
A New York strip steak can be cooked properly in several ways but is typically grilled, pan-fried, or broiled on a wire rack.
New York strip steaks are relatively simple to grill because they do not have a lot of fat. That means you are less likely to have flare-ups when grilling.
Just be sure not to overcook it, as this can make the steak tough. Grilling hot and fast is the best way to get a nice char on the outside while keeping the inside rare or medium-rare.
If you pan-fry your steak, you will want to use a bit of olive oil in the pan to help cook it evenly.
Read More: NY Steak With Cilantro Onion Dredge Recipe
5 Characteristics of Ribeye
Now let's take a look at ribeye steaks.
The ribeye steak is cut from the rib prime cut of the cow. The rib section is the area between the shoulder and loin, right in front of where the New York strip steak comes from. Usually, the meat is harvested from ribs 6-12.
Since the rib area does not have well-exercised muscles, the meat comes with a good amount of fat marbling.
Like the strip, the ribeye steak is taken from the longissimus dorsi muscle strips, which is why it is also a tender cut of beef. Some cuts will contain the spinalis dorsi and complexus muscles.
2. Shape and Size
Ribeyes are not as narrow as New York strip steaks and have a more oval or round shape. They also may have a significant fatty area running through them where the longissimus and spinalis muscles come together.
These steaks are typically fairly thick; you want them to be at least an inch thick. They can also be quite large, with some weighing as much as 16 ounces.
Finally, you can get either a bone-in or boneless ribeye. Many think that bone-in adds flavor to the steak, but it does make cutting and eating more challenging.
Ribeyes also goes by a few different names, including:
- Delmonico steak
- Market steak
- Spencer steak
- Beauty steak
- Cowboy cut
- Scotch fillet
4. Taste and Texture
The ribeye is known for being a flavorful steak. The bone attached and fat content of the meat provide richness and fatty flavor that other steaks do not have. The marbling also helps keep the steak moist, even if it is overcooked.
The ribeye is also a very tender steak, making it a popular choice for those who want a juicy steak. This is due to a large amount of marbling in the meat. Internal marbling gives the beef an almost buttery texture.
You can cook ribeye in many ways, but they are most often grilled, pan-fried, or broiled.
Grilling ribeye can be challenging because of its high-fat content. The fat running down can cause flare-ups with high heat, so you must be careful when grilling and have your tongs nearby. The fat level also makes this best cooked medium-rare to medium-well.
"Cooking steak is a joy because it is a terrific piece of meat that has great flavour whether it is grilled or pan-fried."
- John Torode
It also may help to use a two-zone grilling technique. Initially sear the outside over high heat and then shift to more indirect heat so that you can control the temperature and prevent the steak from flaring.
When cooking ribeye, I almost always opt for pan-searing, which is a good option if you do not want to deal with the potential problems of grilling. The fat content of the ribeye may mean that you do not need to add oil to the pan. This is super important if you’re on a regimen or just want to keep your fat intake to a minimum.
Read More: How to Grill Ribeye Steak?
4 Key Differences Between NY Strip and Ribeye
Now that we have some information about New York strip and ribeye steak, let's look at some of the key differences between these two popular cuts of beef.
The first difference is the amount of marbling. The New York strip has less marbling than the ribeye, which means it will be a leaner, healthier steak cut. The ribeye, coming from the rib section, is known for its rich flavor due to its higher saturated fat content.
Although both ribeye and strip steaks have a far more tender texture than cuts such as the flank or skirt steak, the ribeye is typically considered to be the more delicate of the two. This is due to the steak's higher fat, making it more moist and juicy. The strip has the tighter texture of the two steak cuts.
The third difference is price. Ribeye is typically a more expensive steak cut than New York strip. That said, you are really only looking at $1-2 per pound more for a ribeye premium steak when purchased at butcher shops or the grocery store . Of course, the price differential in a restaurant may be significantly more.
Both the ribeye and New York strip taste great when prepared over the charcoal or gas grill. It is one of the best cooking methods for these steaks. However, the New York strip is easier to cook since it has less fat. The ribeye can be more challenging to grill because the fat can cause flares.
You can also cook either steak using the reverse sear method to get the internal temperature to 145 degrees Fahrenheit on a meat thermometer.
Is a NY Strip Steak or Ribeye Better?
Now that you know the critical differences between a NY strip steak and ribeye steak, you can decide which one is right for you. No matter which one you choose, they are both great options for a delicious, juicy steak. Just remember to cook them properly so that they are at their best.
If you're looking for a service to bring quality, grass-fed New York strip and ribeye steaks to your door, my honest recommendation goes to ButcherBox. They offer a wide variety of premium meats, all from animals humanely raised and free of antibiotics and hormones. Click here to learn more.