With so many lump charcoal brands on the market, you probably can’t decide which one to choose.
To help you avoid wasting money on low-grade lump charcoal, we’ve battle-tested numerous brands for you. After using the charcoals ourselves, we also checked their online reviews and came up with a guide on how to choose the one that meets your specific needs.
Here are our top six picks based on hours of research and grilling.
The Best Lump Charcoals
- Best Overall Lump Charcoal: Jealous Devil Natural
- Cheapest Lump Charcoal: Kamado Joe Big Block
- Best Hardwood Lump Charcoal: Royal Oak Hardwood Lump Charcoal
- Best High-Quality Charcoal: Cowboy Hardwood Lump Charcoal
- Best Lump Charcoal for Kamado Grills: Kamado Joe Big Block
- Best Lump Charcoal for Slow Smoking: Jealous Devil Natural
- Best Lump Charcoal With Minimal Ash: Cowboy Hardwood Lump Charcoal
- Lump Charcoal for Best-Tasting Meat: Royal Oak Hardwood
- Best Lump Charcoal from Renewable Resources: Rockwood All-Natural
Top 6 Lump Charcoals
After carefully reviewing dozens of different lump charcoal products on the market, we’ve narrowed down our list to six options that ticked the most boxes.
Here are the six best lump charcoals for grilling anything from white to red meat.
Our Top Products
1 - Jealous Devil Natural (Best Overall & for Slow Smoking)
- Long burn time
- No scrap materials or chemicals
- Doesn’t pop or crackle
- Minimal ash
- On the pricey side
Who is it for?
Who is it for?
- Ideal for high-heat grilling and searing
Who is it not for?
- Not for those looking for low and slow cooking
Final Verdict
Excellent all-around charcoal for both grilling and smoking, providing consistent heat and flavor.
This Jealous Devil is a 100% natural hardwood lump charcoal free of chemicals, fillers, and scrap wood.
We were eager to try it after reading many positive reviews, so we ordered a bag. It was filled with large- to medium-sized pieces of lump charcoal and contained little to no charcoal dust.
That’s how we knew we were dealing with premium natural hardwood lump charcoal right off the bat.
That may be why it is also extremely easy to light and heats up quickly. It burns hot, but you can still use it for slow cooking because of its long burn time.
According to the manufacturers, this natural hardwood lump charcoal can burn for 4+ hours on open grills and 20+ hours in smokers. Most reviewers confirm these claims.
Many have also pointed out that it leaves little to no ash, making the charcoal grill clean-up easier.
Quick Facts:
- Available in 8lb - 20lb bags
- 100% natural quebracho hardwood
- 1100F+ maximum temperature
2 - Royal Oak Hardwood Lump Charcoal (For Best-Tasting Meat)
- Easy to light
- Great flavor
- Budget-friendly
- May contain fillers
Who is it for?
Who is it for?
- Great for grilling enthusiasts who need high heat
Who is it not for?
- Not suitable for those needing longer burn times
Final Verdict
A reliable choice for grilling, offering good heat and minimal ash for easy cleanup.
Royal Oak natural hardwood lump charcoal is made from both light and dark wood: renewable oak, maple, walnut, and hickory hardwood. It doesn’t contain chemicals or additives.
Many meat lovers praise this natural hardwood lump charcoal for its smoky flavor and how well it burns. We also found it easy to light and appreciated that there were virtually no sparks.
After you light it, you’ll have to wait about 15 minutes for the Royal Oak lump charcoal to reach grilling temperature.
But beware, because this lump charcoal may burn faster than what you’re used to, especially when used on a good charcoal grill.
The only downside to this lump charcoal is the inconsistency in quality. Some reviewers were happy with what they received, but some reported finding rocks, nails, and even scrap metal mixed with Royal Oak charcoal in the bags.
Still, it is more affordable than most oak lump charcoal brands, so you’ll still be getting value for your money.
3 - Cowboy Hardwood Lump Charcoal (Best High-Quality & With Least Ash)
- Leaves very little ash
- Great smoky flavor
- Can be used with most outdoor cooking appliances
- Not ideal for low and slow cooking
Who is it for?
Who is it for?
- Perfect for quick and hot grilling sessions
Who is it not for?
- Not ideal for long smoking sessions
Final Verdict
Provides a good balance of heat and burn time, suitable for everyday grilling needs.
Most foodies love Cowboy lump charcoal for two reasons: its flavorful smoke and very little ash production.
Unlike many other lump charcoal options, Cowboy adds a fantastic mild smoky flavor to your meals without making too much mess.
You can use Cowboy lump charcoal in ceramic-style charcoal grills, like the Big Green Egg, barrel grills, and kettle barbecues. So, you could say that this is one of the more versatile charcoals on the market.
It’s on the pricey side, but you do get high-quality charcoal for that price. Our bag was mainly filled with medium-sized chunks and contained very little charcoal dust.
How does this charcoal burn? It may burn too hot and too fast for some meals. Some reviewers mention they had trouble maintaining medium temperature, which isn’t ideal for slow cooking.
Quick Facts:
- 20 lb per bag
- 100% all-natural hardwood lump charcoal
4 - Rockwood All-Natural (Best from Renewable Resources)
- Made from renewable resources
- Nice smoky flavor
- Clean-burning wood
- Lots of smaller pieces in the bag
Who is it for?
Who is it for?
- Great for eco-conscious grillers
Who is it not for?
- Not for those who prefer quick lighting charcoal
Final Verdict
High-quality, eco-friendly charcoal with excellent flavor and low ash production.
Rockwood all-natural hardwood charcoal is an excellent option for those that care about sustainability.
For starters, this lump charcoal is made exclusively from hardwood left from timber milling — namely Missouri oak, hickory, maple, and pecan. On top of that, the bag it comes in is 100% recyclable and landfill-safe.
The natural charcoal itself has a rich aroma and produces a smoky flavor. We liked that it burns hot and clean, leaving you with only small flakes of ash here and there.
Although Rockwood suits any charcoal grill, it works especially well with ceramic-style grills, like the Big Green Egg.
The only problem is the inconsistency in quality. Many reviewers reported receiving tiny pieces of lump charcoal in their bags, while some were delighted with their purchase.
Considering that Rockwood is one of the pricier lump charcoal companies, such differences in quality are disappointing.
Quick Facts:
- 100% natural
- 20 lb per bag
- Recyclable bags
5 - Fogo Super Premium Hardwood Lump Charcoal
- Very easy to light even without lighter fluid
- Distinct flavor (sweet)
- Ample burning time
- The super premium lump charcoal chunks may be too large
Fogo Super Premium is ideal for those who like to cook slowly and long. Like Rockwood, Fogo is also more suitable for ceramic-style grills, such as the Big Green Egg.
The company promises that every bag contains XL pieces, and reviewers largely confirm that to be true.
Many of them report finding huge chunks of charcoal in their bags, which made their cooking much more enjoyable.
If you want our take, there are two things we particularly like about Fogo Super Premium lump charcoal.
Firstly, it has a distinct, sweet flavor that you rarely get with other lump charcoals. Secondly, lighting this charcoal is a breeze even if you don’t use lighter fluid.
The only downside is that the chunks may be too large and difficult to place. So, you may have to waste time breaking them into smaller pieces, or you may not even be able to use them with smaller appliances.
Quick Facts:
- 17.6 lbs per bag
- 80% of the bag consists of pieces of 4 inches or larger
6 - Kamado Joe Big Block Lump Charcoal (Cheapest & Best for Kamado Grills)
- Perfect for slow smoking or grilling
- Mainly large- to medium-sized chunks
- Easy to light
- Too much ash
Who is it for?
Who is it for?
- Perfect for Kamado style grills
Who is it not for?
- Not suitable for small portable grills
Final Verdict
Excellent for Kamado grills, offering long burn time and the ability to reuse charcoal for multiple sessions.
This 100% natural lump charcoal is made explicitly for Kamado grills. But it works well with other ceramic-style grills, too.
Most reviewers report getting mainly good-sized chunks and finding little to no crumbs and debris. That’s the first sign of a high-quality product.
We’ve further tested the quality in my backyard. The charcoal didn’t pop or crackle while being lit, which was yet another positive sign.
Another pro is that Kamado Joe is also long-burning lump charcoal. Its steady burn can last up to 18 hours, which is perfect for low and slow cooking.
The only thing that could improve is the amount of ash left after using this charcoal. Charcoal ash is bad for the environment and your health, so we’d prefer to see less of it [1].
Quick Facts:
- 20 or 30 lbs per bag
- Burning time up to 18 hours
- 100% natural
How To Choose The Right Charcoal
Most foodies initially struggle to find the right charcoal for their needs, tastes, and cooking appliances. It usually takes some hit-and-miss until you get it right.
To help you speed up the process, we put together this super-quick guide for you.
Consider these three things when choosing your charcoal, and we guarantee you’ll be happy with your purchase.
Flavor
The first thing to consider is what smoky flavor you want to get from your charcoal. Here’s a rule of thumb you can follow:
- Lighter woods — Typically produce a sweet and subtle flavor that best suits white meat. Think maple and pecan.
- Darker woods — Typically leave a stronger flavor better suited for red meat. Think oak and hickory.
For example, let’s say you want a subtle flavor. In that case, you should avoid oak or hickory lump charcoal to achieve a mild flavor. Instead, you need charcoal made from lighter wood — like Fogo Super Premium lump charcoal.
Burn Time
Next, consider how long you want your charcoal to burn. It depends on two things:
- The size of charcoal
- Wood density
Unfortunately, you can’t influence whether you’ll get big or smaller charcoal chunks. But you can choose the right wood density for your needs.
You only need to follow a simple formula: the denser the wood, the longer it burns.
So, you should choose charcoal made from denser wood for slow and long cooking. For example, hickory is an incredibly dense wood that can burn for hours.
On the other hand, lighter woods like maple are better for burgers and other quick meals.
So, consider the meals you want to make first and then choose charcoal based on that.
Quality
Low-quality lump charcoal typically contains lots of fillers and chemicals that are bad for your health and the environment. So, we suggest avoiding cheap charcoal at all costs.
But maybe you’re wondering how to recognize low-quality charcoal in the first place. Here are two ways to do so.
Firstly, check if your light lump charcoal bag contains broken pieces, dust, or scrap materials. If so, you’re probably dealing with an inferior product.
But even the best lump charcoals can get damaged in transit. So, broken pieces may not necessarily mean the product is low-quality, especially when it has very little dust.
That’s why you also want to focus on what happens when you light lump charcoal.
If it’s producing too many sparks or too much ash, you’ll know that you didn’t get a good product. That’s when you should consider other options.
Related Articles:
FAQs
Is Lump Charcoal Any Good?
Lump charcoal is good. It’s generally considered better and higher quality than charcoal briquettes.
How Big Should Lump Charcoal Be?
Lump charcoal should be from 1 to 4 inches in size.
Can You Use the Snake Method With Lump Charcoal?
You can use the snake method with lump charcoal, but it’s not an easy feat because of the variations in charcoal chunk sizes and shapes.
What Is The Best Lump Charcoal?
Our impression is that Jealous Devil is the best lump charcoal even by the highest foodie standards. And apparently, we’re not alone. Other reviewers raved about it too, compared to some charcoal briquettes on the market.
“Been using this charcoal for a while now and I couldn't be more pleased. Great flavor imparted by the smoke…”
- JCinPC from Florida
“Buy this charcoal! I have had a big green egg for over a decade and have used several different brands of charcoal on countless smokes and grills. This charcoal is absolutely the best one in terms of coal size, density, heat, longevity and lack of foreign objects.”
- Dan from Southern California
No matter how many charcoals we’ve tried, we’ve found ourselves constantly going back to this high-quality product. It produces minimal ash, lights easily, and doesn’t pop or crackle.
But what won us over was the size and quality of the chunks inside the bag. Our bag contained zero dust, crumbs, and debris. The Jealous Devil ticks all the boxes.
Jealous Devil Natural (Best Overall & for Slow Smoking)
Our #1 Recommendation
Rated With Carnivore Style's Scoring System
- Long burn time
- No scrap materials or chemicals
- Doesn’t pop or crackle
- Minimal ash
- On the pricey side
